← Research Complete

Infrastructure

Internet, power and cabling

Recommendation

What we recommend

Keep Lightwire Fixed Wireless Unlimited ($139/month, 24-month contract) as the sole Phase 1 internet connection — the house-to-shed fibre cable run is confirmed complete and live, and the shed-end network is a single settled state end to end: router, fibre link, and PoE switch are all installed and working. Stay on Option C (no backup) through Phase 1, and add a 4G mobile backup router (TP-Link MR6400, re-verified NZ retail $119–$159) on a Spark Business or One NZ IoT SIM in Phase 2, once on-site cellular coverage is confirmed.

Why

  • The cable run is done and the shed switch question is fully closed: the TP-Link TL-SG116P (16-port PoE+, 120W budget) is confirmed purchased and installed and connected at the shed router. There was never a separate interim non-PoE switch. The compound requirements document has now settled on this state across three consecutive same-day corrections, and today's refresh confirms nothing further has changed.
  • The compound requirements (v9) clarify that the NVR's own built-in PoE ports form a dedicated, self-contained camera-only network — separate from, and non-competing with, the TL-SG116P switch's 120W/16-port budget. That budget remains fully available for the alarm communicator and future access-control readers regardless of which NVR is chosen, with no further switch decision needed.
  • All safety-critical systems continue working through a Lightwire outage regardless of any of the above: the NVR keeps recording locally, EasyGate customer access runs on its own batteries, and the alarm panel fails over automatically to its own independent cellular path. Only remote camera viewing and remote PIN management are lost, and that is explicitly accepted as Phase 1 risk.
  • H.265 encoding on every camera is what keeps worst-case concurrent upload demand (~3.5 Mbps) inside Lightwire's ~5 Mbps typical upload ceiling — this is a disqualifying criterion for camera procurement, not a lever on the internet plan itself.
  • Today's live re-verification pass reconfirmed Lightwire at $139/month unchanged (direct fetch of lightwire.co), and reconfirmed current NZ stock and pricing for the TP-Link MR6400 ($119–$159 across 7+ retailers). Starlink pricing has risen further since mid-June 2026 (Residential Standard now $170/month, up from $159) and remains more expensive than the entire Phase 2 backup solution for a role that only restores non-critical remote viewing — it stays unrecommended.

Cost estimate

Phase 1 cable run (one-off, work now complete): ~$750–$1,100 planning estimate (conduit + labour; fibre/converter/SFP hardware already purchased separately). Not yet reconciled against actual invoiced cost — a financial record-keeping task, not a connectivity decision.

Phase 1 ongoing: $139/month — Lightwire Fixed Wireless Unlimited, re-verified live 2026-08-05, unchanged.

PoE switch (one-off, resolved — no remaining spend): TP-Link TL-SG116P already purchased and installed; $0 further cost or action required.

Phase 2 hardware (one-off, re-verified 2026-08-05): TP-Link MR6400, $119–$159 NZD, confirmed current stock across 7+ NZ retailers. (The VoIP-capable MR6500v variant is $249+ and not needed for this application.)

Phase 2 SIM (ongoing, still not costed): Spark Business IoT SIM and One NZ IoT SIM both confirmed to exist as products, but neither publishes pricing — a direct quote is required from each, and from reseller M2M One as a comparison. Treat $15–$25/month as an unconfirmed planning estimate only.

Combined Phase 2 monthly total (planning estimate, pending SIM quote): ~$154–$164/month

What is still to decide

  • Highest priority, and not blocked by anything physical: run the Lightwire peak-hour upload speed test at the shed (3pm–10pm weekday, target consistently ≥3.5 Mbps). This has been open since 2026-04-09 (four months) and remains the single most important outstanding action on the whole internet plan — the link is confirmed working, so there is no remaining installation reason it cannot be done today.
  • Get Lightwire's fair-use/throttling policy in writing, and confirm the exact CPE model at the house and which LAN port the media converter uses — both still unresolved.
  • Reconcile the actual invoiced cable-run cost against the ~$750–$1,100 planning estimate, now the physical work is done — a financial record-keeping task.
  • Confirm 4G/5G signal strength at the shed on both Spark and One NZ before committing to any Phase 2 hardware spend — a physical walk-test, separate from and not resolved by the cable run being complete.
  • Get direct pricing quotes for a Spark Business or One NZ IoT SIM (and a comparison quote from M2M One) before budgeting Phase 2 — neither carrier publishes pricing.
  • UPS size: 1000 VA/600W is the specified minimum, giving only 5–10 minutes at full Phase 1 load; a 1500 VA/900W unit is worth Ed weighing given rural power outages can be prolonged.
  • The alarm communicator model itself (TL280LE, as distinct from the now-resolved switch question) still needs confirming as actually purchased — see requirements.md and integration.md for the current specification.

Decisions already taken

DateDecisionWhat this locks in
2026-03-31Run fibre cable from house to shed — Easter 2026 (~18 Apr)Cable route confirmed on Easter visit; Lightwire primary provider. The run itself is confirmed complete and working — this does not change what the decision locked in, only its completion status.

Outstanding assignments

TaskAreaExpected by
Connect and confirm internet cable to shedInternetTBD — Ed has directly reported the cable run is complete and working. The formal assignment record in context/assignments.md has not yet been updated to reflect this; what remains under this line item is the peak-hour speed test and CPE/fair-use confirmation, not physical installation.

Blocked by

No blockers recorded in context/open-items.md for this area. The peak-hour upload test and fair-use confirmation (open since 2026-04-09) and the 4G/5G coverage walk-test are significant outstanding action items, but neither is an external dependency blocking this area — see "What is still to decide" above.

Options Considered Vendor and product options with costs and trade-offs

This is the Tier 3 internet/connectivity sourcing pass (working/internet/source-internet.md, re-verified live 2026-08-05). This is a light refresh of the prior publish: the cable run status, the Lightwire plan, the 4G backup hardware pricing, and the Starlink pricing were all re-checked live today and found unchanged in substance from the last publish. No pricing regressions and no discontinued hardware were found.

Cable Run to Shed

Status: CONFIRMED COMPLETE. Ed has directly confirmed the fibre cable has been run to the shed and is working.

Hardware installed — settled state:

ItemDetail
Cable200m 6-core OS2 LC-LC pre-terminated single-mode fibre on drum
House endTP-Link MC210CS SC-port gigabit media converter + Dynamix FSM-LCSC-1 LC-SC patch lead
Shed endStarTech SFPGLCLHSMST 1000BASE-LX LC SFP transceiver module in ER706W WAN/LAN port
Distance~200m — well within OS2 single-mode range (rated to 10km at 1310nm)
Shed LANER706W router with the TP-Link TL-SG116P (16-port PoE+ Gigabit switch, 120W PoE budget) connected downstream of it — purchased and installed, live today

Settled state (unchanged this refresh): the TL-SG116P was purchased some time ago and has been installed and connected at the shed router all along. There was never a separate interim non-PoE switch — an earlier miscommunication to that effect was corrected and resettled in an earlier pass, and today's re-verification confirms no further change. It has 120W of PoE budget across 16 ports, ample headroom for the alarm communicator and future access-control readers whenever those are installed — no further switch procurement or installation decision remains. (Cameras still connect directly to the NVR's own built-in PoE ports, not to this switch — see requirements.md and integration.md for the full PoE architecture.)

What remains open on this line item:

  • Reconcile the actual invoiced cost of the trench/conduit/labour against the ~$750–$1,100 planning estimate below — a record-keeping task, not a decision point
  • Run the post-cable-run peak-hour speed test from the shed end via the ER706W (see Open Questions) — not yet done, and not blocked by anything physical

Estimated costs (planning figures, not yet reconciled against actual spend):

ItemEstimated cost (NZD incl. GST)
Alkathene conduit (2 x 100m rolls, 25mm)$260–$320
Gland/fitting sets (x2 ends)$40–$80
Mini-excavator hire (half day)$400–$600
Reinstatement materials (topsoil, lawn seed)$50–$100
Total cable run (excl. already-purchased fibre hardware)$750–$1,100

Primary Connectivity

Option A -- Lightwire Fixed Wireless Unlimited

Status: Locked in — not subject to selection. Ed is under a 24-month contract. Live, working, and confirmed reaching the shed end-to-end.

ParameterDetail
ProviderLightwire
TechnologyFixed wireless (FWA)
Download speed10 Mbps guaranteed peak; higher typical
Upload speed~5 Mbps typical, not speed-guaranteed
Monthly cost$139/month (24-month Unlimited contract) — re-verified live 2026-08-05 via direct fetch of lightwire.co/homes, unchanged and correctly priced
Data capUnlimited
Install fee"Free installation (valued at $650)" per this session's fetch — standing marketing offer for new sign-ups, not relevant to Ed's already-installed connection
ModemFree WiFi modem included
Extras"Threat Feed Service" included on all plans

Plan comparison (fetched from lightwire.co/homes, 2026-08-05):

PlanPrice/monthDataTermVerdict
90GB Low Usage$7990GB12 moNot suitable — capped
300GB Stream Starter$95300GB12 moNot suitable — capped
Unlimited (24-month)$139Unlimited24 moContracted plan — confirmed current
Unlimited (12-month)$155Unlimited12 moMore expensive; irrelevant, Ed is under contract

A promotion ("2 months free," code SUMMERCREDIT, stated valid through 20 March 2026) was observed on the plan page but that date has already passed — this reads as stale marketing copy and is not actionable.

Requirements compliance:

RequirementLightwire UnlimitedVerdict
5 Mbps sustained upload~5 Mbps typical (not guaranteed)MARGINAL — meets typical demand only; peak-hour behaviour still unverified
10 Mbps download10 Mbps guaranteed peakPASS
Data capUnlimitedPASS
Fair use / throttling policyNot published on the public plan pageUNVERIFIED — still open, now four months overdue
H.265 3.5 Mbps burstFits within ~5 Mbps upload with no headroom for additional upload consumersPASS, provided no additional demand is added

Alternative fixed-line/fibre check: no evidence of a new fibre or competing fixed-wireless provider now serving Te Waerenga Road, Hamurana that would beat Lightwire's upload figures. Rural Hamurana has historically sat outside the UFB fibre footprint, and Ed is contractually locked into a 24-month Lightwire term regardless. Recommendation: do not pursue a switch.

Risks: upload is not speed-guaranteed; peak-hour congestion on the fixed-wireless tower is unverified — this is the single biggest open risk in the whole internet plan, and it is trivially actionable (a speed test plus a phone call).


Backup Connectivity Options (Phase 2)

The following address backup/failover only. The primary Lightwire link (Option A above) is not subject to selection.

Option B -- 4G Mobile Backup Router

What it provides: a cellular router on the ER706W's WAN2 port, providing failover connectivity when Lightwire drops.

Hardware (re-verified live NZ retail pricing and availability, 2026-08-05):

HardwareCost (NZD incl. GST)Notes
TP-Link TL-MR6400 4G LTE router (N300, CAT4)$119–$159Cheapest via PriceMe ($119.11–$125.55 depending on search pass); also confirmed listed at PriceSpy ($159), PB Tech, Mighty Ape, Rubbermonkey, Ascent, and Acquire.co.nz. Confirmed current stock across 7+ independent NZ retailers this session — some retailer pages returned bot-blocking on direct fetch, so confirmation was via search/comparison-site indexing rather than page-by-page fetch for those. This is the recommended model — cheapest option meeting the WAN-port failover requirement.
TP-Link TL-MR6500v 4G LTE router (N300, with VoIP)$249 cheapestConfirmed current listing at PriceSpy, Jaycar NZ, Tech Supply Shed, and Essential Security Supplies. Adds VoIP/telephony support not needed here. Despite the model name, this is still 4G/LTE CAT4 only, not 5G.

Recommendation on hardware: the MR6400 at ~$119–$159 is the right choice — it meets the WAN2 failover requirement, is the cheapest option, and is confirmed as a currently-listed, actively-sold model across multiple independent NZ retailers this session. The MR6500v's extra ~$90–$130 buys VoIP telephony capability that is not needed here.

SIM/plan options — re-verified 2026-08-05:

ProviderPlanMonthly costNotes
Spark BusinessIoT/M2M SIMNot published — direct quote requiredProduct line confirmed current and active (IoT connectivity, device management, cost-optimisation guidance); no per-plan pricing published anywhere on the site
One NZIoT Local Connectivity Data Bundle / PAYGNot published — direct quote requiredCurrent plan structures confirmed (data bundle or per-connection); references a separate, non-public "Pricing Schedule -- IoT Managed Connectivity" document. One NZ implemented a broader price-change round from 22 April 2026, so treat any prior estimate as unconfirmed until directly quoted
M2M One (IoT SIM reseller/aggregator)IoT SIM plans across NZ carriers, "0.5MB to 1TB, no lock-in contracts"Not published — direct quote or free-trial signup requiredConfirmed active NZ-based IoT SIM reseller with a dedicated but pricing-gated "SIM Pricing" page

All three IoT SIM pricing pages remain gated behind a sales quote as of this session — unchanged from the prior research pass. Treat any prior "$15–$25/month" planning estimate as an unconfirmed placeholder only, not a verified figure, until an actual quote is obtained.

Requirements compliance:

  • Backup bandwidth: PASS — rural 4G typically 2-10 Mbps upload, well above the ~1 Mbps backup-mode demand — pending the coverage test below
  • Alarm cellular independence: PASS — the alarm communicator has its own separate SIM/path, entirely unaffected by this router
  • Gate/NVR offline behaviour: NOT APPLICABLE — both are independent of any internet path, backup included

Phase 1 cost: $0 (deferred to Phase 2, per guidance)

Phase 2 cost (this session's re-verified hardware price range): ~$119–$159 hardware (MR6400, one-off) + IoT SIM monthly cost (unconfirmed pending quote) = hardware cost confirmed; ongoing cost still requires a direct quote from Spark Business, One NZ, or M2M One before budgeting

What this locks in: nothing contractual — IoT SIMs are typically no-term or short-term per all three providers' own product descriptions

Risks:

  • 4G/5G coverage at the shed is still unconfirmed on-site — a physical walk-test with test SIMs on both Spark and One NZ, not something research can resolve. This is the binding prerequisite before any Phase 2 hardware spend, and is entirely independent of the (now-complete) fibre cable run.
  • Actual IoT SIM pricing is not published by any of the three providers checked this session — get a direct quote before committing
  • Rural 4G upload is lower and more variable than Lightwire; acceptable for backup-mode (alarm heartbeat + occasional live-view), not as a primary link

Verdict: recommended for Phase 2, subject to on-site 4G coverage check and IoT SIM quotes.


Option C -- No Backup (Phase 1)

What this means: Lightwire remains the sole internet path through Phase 1. No backup hardware purchased or configured.

Operational impact during a Lightwire outage:

SystemBehaviour during outageOperational impact
NVR / camerasContinues recording locally to on-site NVR storageNone — footage preserved
EasyGate pin padOperates on its own batteries; no network dependencyNone — customer gate access unaffected
Alarm panelAutomatically fails over to its own cellular pathNone — alarm remains functional
Remote camera viewUnavailableCannot remotely view cameras
Remote PIN managementUnavailableCannot add or remove access codes remotely

Phase 1 cost: $0 additional — Lightwire $139/month only.

Pros: zero additional cost; simplest configuration; all safety-critical functions remain operational during outages; ER706W WAN2 stays available for Phase 2 without any hardware change already made.

Cons: remote camera view and remote PIN management are lost during any Lightwire outage; on-site physical access is needed to review footage during an outage.

Verdict: recommended for Phase 1, unchanged conclusion this refresh.


What it would provide: satellite-based backup or primary connectivity, independent of local fixed-wireless tower congestion.

Live-verified NZ pricing, 2026-08-05 (via secondary-source corroboration — direct fetch of starlink.com/nz returned no retrievable content this session):

PlanPrice (NZD)Notes
Residential Lite$85/monthEntry-level, lower priority data allocation
Residential Standard$170/monthStandard priority; up from $159 in mid-June 2026
Roam (mobile)$50/month for 50GBDesigned for RVs/boats, not fixed-site use
Hardware (dish + router kit)~$799 one-offSome secondary/resale listings quote lower, but $799 is the figure consistently reported against Starlink's own current NZ pricing this session

Verification note: these figures are corroborated across three independent, current (2026) NZ-focused secondary sources rather than a direct fetch of Starlink's own page, which is a weaker verification standard than the direct-fetch confirmation achieved for Lightwire.

Why it is still not recommended: even at the cheaper Residential Lite tier ($85/month), Starlink as a backup-only connection costs more per month than the entire MR6400 + IoT SIM 4G backup solution, for a role that only restores remote visibility — not any operationally critical function (gate access, alarm, and recording all continue regardless of internet status). At Residential Standard ($170/month), it now costs more than the primary Lightwire plan itself. Prices have risen, not fallen, since the prior pass, which strengthens rather than weakens the case against Starlink as backup.

Verdict: not recommended. Only reconsider if the Phase 2 4G walk-test comes back negative for both Spark and One NZ coverage — get a live, current Starlink NZ quote at that point, as pricing has moved twice in recent months.


PhaseSetupMonthly cost (NZD incl. GST)
Phase 1Lightwire only (Option A + Option C) — live and working$139/month
Phase 2 (recommended, coverage permitting)Lightwire + 4G mobile backup (Option A + Option B)~$154–$164/month (pending actual IoT SIM quote)

Network Configuration Notes

ER706W VLAN and firewall configuration:

  • VLAN 10 — Camera network: NVR + all IP cameras; outbound to Hik-Connect relay servers only; deny inbound from VLAN 20; no port forwarding
  • VLAN 20 — Management network: alarm communicator, access control system, operator devices on-site; outbound to alarm monitoring cloud and general internet; deny inbound from VLAN 10
  • Router hardening: change all default passwords (ER706W, TL-SG116P switch, cameras, NVR); disable UPnP; disable remote management unless VPN is configured; enable firewall logging
  • WAN failover (Phase 2): WAN1 = Lightwire (primary), WAN2 = 4G router (failover only, not load-balancing); health check against 8.8.8.8 and 1.1.1.1 on both links

Speed test and upload monitoring — the single highest-priority open action:

  • Overdue peak-hour test: run speedtest.net or fast.com from the ER706W at the shed during peak hours (3pm-10pm weekday); upload should be consistently at or above 3.5 Mbps. Open since 2026-04-09, still not done as of this refresh, and not blocked by installation status.
  • Fibre-link-integrity check: while running the above test, confirm the shed-end reading is consistent with the house-end connection, to rule out any loss introduced by the media converter/SFP/fibre run itself.
  • Ongoing monitoring: review ER706W WAN bandwidth logs monthly for unexpected upload consumers (e.g. accidental NVR cloud backup).

NZ Supplier Options for Networking Hardware — Verification Summary (this session, 2026-08-05)

ItemSupplier optionsIndicative price (NZD incl. GST)Verification status
Lightwire Unlimited 24-month planLightwire$139/monthPrimary-source confirmed — direct live fetch of lightwire.co/homes, 2026-08-05
TP-Link MR6400 4G LTE router (Phase 2)PriceMe, PriceSpy, PB Tech, Mighty Ape, Rubbermonkey, Ascent, Acquire.co.nz$119–$159Found via search/comparison-site indexing — individual retailer pages returned bot-blocking on direct fetch this session; price and current-listing status corroborated across 7+ independent NZ retailers
TP-Link MR6500v 4G LTE router (Phase 2 alternative)PriceSpy, Jaycar NZ, Tech Supply Shed, Essential Security Supplies$249 (cheapest found)Same verification level as above
Spark Business IoT SIM (Phase 2)Spark BusinessNot published — quote requiredProduct line confirmed current and active 2026-08-05; pricing not public on any page found
One NZ IoT SIM (Phase 2)One NZNot published — quote requiredProduct line confirmed current and active 2026-08-05; pricing not public on any page found
M2M One (IoT SIM reseller)M2M OneNot published — quote requiredConfirmed active NZ business with a dedicated pricing-request page; no published rates
Starlink NZ (backup, not recommended)StarlinkResidential Lite $85/mo, Residential Standard $170/mo, Roam $50/mo (50GB), hardware ~$799Secondary-source corroborated, not primary-page-confirmed — direct fetch to starlink.com/nz returned no content this session; figures cross-checked across 3 independent current NZ Starlink pricing/review sources
Farmlands / RD1 / Placemakers alkathene conduitLocal Rotorua branches of Farmlands, RD1, Placemakers$90–$160/roll (100m)Not re-verified this session — carried forward as a planning estimate; largely moot now the cable run is complete, relevant only to confirming actual spend
TP-Link TL-SG116P PoE switch (shed, already purchased and installed)N/A — already owned, no further sourcing needed16-port PoE+, 120W budgetPurchase/installation status confirmed by Ed and by infrastructure-requirements.md; no supplier action required
Cross-System Requirements How this area interacts with other systems and constraints

Source

Integration design is drawn from .claude/knowledge/integration/security-infrastructure.md (version 9, last-updated 2026-08-05, status POPULATED). This is a targeted refresh of the prior (v7) publish. v9's substantive change is a correction to a stale camera-NVR alarm-input assumption (see "NVR alarm inputs" below) plus an explicit clarification of the NVR's PoE architecture — it does not change the shed switch position (settled at v7) or any bandwidth, UPS, or connectivity figure.


How Infrastructure Connects to Other Systems

Cameras (Hik-Connect P2P)

The Hikvision NVR and cameras sit on VLAN 10. The NVR registers with Hik-Connect, Hikvision's cloud relay service. Remote live-view and playback are available via the Hik-Connect app or iVMS-4200 desktop client without port forwarding or a static IP address.

The NVR requires outbound access to Hik-Connect relay servers (TCP 80, 443, and Hik-Connect-specific ports including 8000, 8200, and 554 for RTSP). The ER706W firewall must allow these outbound connections from VLAN 10 and deny all inbound connections from the internet to the camera VLAN. No direct internet exposure of any camera or the NVR is required or recommended.

If the internet drops, the NVR continues recording locally. Hik-Connect remote view is unavailable until connectivity is restored — an explicitly accepted Phase 1 risk, and a live-tested condition rather than a theoretical one, since the fibre link to the shed is confirmed working.

Bandwidth constraint (load-bearing, unchanged): H.265 encoding is mandatory on all cameras. The Lightwire upload ceiling (~5 Mbps typical) is only met if all cameras use H.265. H.264 would approximately double the upstream live-view sub-stream demand and risk breaching the ceiling under concurrent use. This is a disqualifying criterion for camera procurement, not a preference.

NVR alarm inputs — corrected v9: earlier passes treated the NVR's alarm-input count as needing to scale with bay count (read in practice as "≥8 alarm inputs required"), which wrongly excluded or down-ranked NVR models with fewer inputs. This was a stale assumption about wiring topology, not a real requirement: the 12 bay-door reed switches wire into the alarm panel's own zones, not the NVR, and the panel sends a single PGM relay trigger to just one NVR alarm input. The corrected floor is a minimum of 1 NVR alarm input (2 if a second PGM output is used for a separate purpose). This does not change any internet, bandwidth, or connectivity requirement — it is a camera/NVR sourcing correction, noted here because it flows from the same v9 refresh.

NVR PoE architecture — clarified v9: the NVR's own built-in PoE ports (e.g. the 16-port budget on a DS-7616NI-K2/16P) form a dedicated, self-contained network for cameras only. They are not a general-purpose switch — they do not extend network access to non-camera devices and do not compete with or reduce the capacity of the separately-owned TL-SG116P switch, which remains fully available for the alarm communicator and future access-control readers regardless of which NVR is chosen.

Alarms (Dual-Path Communicator)

The alarm communicator sits on VLAN 20 (management). It uses the internet path (IP primary) to send heartbeats and alarm events to the monitoring centre. If the IP path drops, it automatically fails over to its own cellular SIM — mandatory, not a nice-to-have.

Communicator model (unaffected by this refresh): the required communicator is the TL280LE (LTE 4G + Ethernet, $499 NZD at Alarm Warehouse NZ). The previously specified TL2803GR is obsolete 3G/HSPA-only hardware and has been non-functional since New Zealand's nationwide 3G network shutdown completed 2 April 2026 — it must not be procured, and if one has already been purchased it needs physically exchanging, not just correcting on paper. TL280E (IP-only, no cellular backup) is excluded for the Grade 3 target. Whether the correct TL280LE unit has actually been purchased and installed remains a separate, still-open question — this is genuinely unresolved, and is not the same question as the switch, which is settled.

Switch dependency (settled, unchanged this refresh): the communicator's ethernet/IP path depends on a PoE switch being purchased and installed. That dependency is fully resolved on the switch side — the TL-SG116P is confirmed purchased and already installed and in use at the shed. This is true regardless of which communicator model ends up fitted; it does not, on its own, resolve the separate open question of which communicator model has actually been purchased. The cellular path is, and always was, independent of both the switch and the router's WAN status.

The ER706W being on UPS is important here: keeping the router online during a brief power outage delays the point at which the alarm communicator loses its IP path and triggers cellular fallback, reducing unnecessary cellular-path alarm traffic during short power cuts.

The alarm communicator's cellular SIM is entirely independent of any Phase 2 4G backup router SIM — separate devices on separate networks. The alarm panel's cellular path is unaffected by whether the backup router is functioning.

Access Control (EasyGate Phase 1 — No Network Dependency)

The EasyGate wireless keypad (433.92 MHz RF, HCS101 rolling code) operates entirely independently of the network — no data interface, no API, no audit log, no network connectivity. Customer gate access is not affected by any internet or network outage.

In Phase 1, the gate camera (on VLAN 10, NVR-recorded) and a manual PIN register are the sole access records. The gate camera specification is therefore load-bearing for consent evidence — it must capture vehicle registration plates and driver identity clearly enough to substitute for a digital access log.

In Phase 2, a wired Wiegand or OSDP reader wired to an access control panel (e.g. Inner Range Inception or DS-K2602) will be added on VLAN 20. Like the alarm communicator, a PoE reader/panel will draw from the shed's PoE switch — the TL-SG116P is confirmed purchased and already installed at the shed with 120W/16-port budget and ample headroom for this, so no separate switch procurement is needed for Phase 2 sequencing. Remote management of customer PIN codes requires an internet connection; during a Lightwire outage, remote PIN management is unavailable and the gate must continue operating on locally stored credentials.


VLAN Topology


Lightwire (house) -> MC210CS media converter -> OS2 fibre (CONFIRMED COMPLETE) -> ER706W SFP WAN port (shed)

  ER706W LAN -> TL-SG116P PoE switch (purchased, installed, and connected at the shed router -- settled state)
  NVR built-in PoE ports (VLAN 10) -> IP cameras -- cameras draw PoE directly from the NVR, a dedicated camera-only network, not the switch

  TL-SG116P port group -> alarm communicator (VLAN 20: management) -- IP path no longer switch-blocked
  TL-SG116P port group -> access control panel (VLAN 20: management, Phase 2) -- no switch dependency remains
  ER706W WiFi -> operator use on-site (VLAN 20: management)

VLAN 10 — Camera network:

  • Members: NVR, IP cameras
  • Outbound allowed: Hik-Connect relay servers (TCP 80, 443, 8000, 8200, 554)
  • Inbound from internet: denied — no port forwarding to any camera or NVR
  • Inbound from VLAN 20: denied
  • Lateral movement between cameras: denied
  • NVR to camera access: allowed

VLAN 20 — Management network:

  • Members: alarm communicator, access control panel (Phase 2), operator devices on-site
  • Outbound allowed: alarm monitoring cloud servers, access control cloud service, general internet for management
  • Inbound from VLAN 10: denied

Router hardening (required before deployment):

  • Change default admin password on ER706W, TL-SG116P switch, all cameras and the NVR
  • Disable UPnP on ER706W
  • Disable remote management on ER706W web UI (use Omada cloud controller instead)
  • Enable firewall logging on ER706W for incident investigation

WAN Failover Configuration (Phase 2)

  • WAN1: Lightwire (OS2 fibre via MC210CS into ER706W SFP WAN port) — live and working
  • WAN2: 4G router LAN ethernet into ER706W WAN2 ethernet port
  • Mode: Failover only — NOT load balancing. Camera and alarm traffic must not be split across both WAN links simultaneously.
  • Health check: ER706W pings 8.8.8.8 and 1.1.1.1 on both WAN links; failover triggers automatically when WAN1 health check fails.

Starlink is retained in options.md only as a fallback if on-site 4G coverage proves inadequate — the Phase 2 backup decision is unchanged from the prior pass.


PoE Switch: Fully Resolved (no remaining decision)

Prior versions of this document carried a purchase-timing question, working from a since-corrected position that the switch had not yet been purchased. That question no longer exists and is unchanged by this refresh. The TL-SG116P is confirmed purchased and has been installed and connected at the shed router all along — there was never a separate interim non-PoE switch. source-cameras and source-alarms should both treat the TL-SG116P as existing, installed infrastructure with a 120W/16-port PoE budget available for the alarm communicator and future access control readers; no further switch procurement decision is needed. A prior Tier 3 recommendation to purchase a standalone TL-SG108PE for the alarm/access-control PoE need is moot and has been dropped from options.md.


UPS Requirements

Cameras connect directly to the NVR's own built-in 16-port PoE budget (230W budget on the DS-7616NI-K2/16P), not to the switch — this is a dedicated, self-contained camera-only network (clarified v9). The TL-SG116P (120W budget across 16 ports, confirmed purchased and installed) carries only the alarm communicator, future access control readers, and other peripherals — not cameras.

Systems that must stay online during a mains power outage:

SystemReasonBackup source
NVR (DS-7616NI-K2/16P), including camera PoE drawMust continue local recording; cameras are powered directly from the NVR, not the switchExternal UPS
TL-SG116P PoE switch (purchased and installed, in use at the shed)Powers alarm communicator and future access control readers (not cameras)External UPS
Router (ER706W)Maintains alarm communicator IP path while availableExternal UPS
Alarm panelContinues arming/detection/cellular comms via its dual-path communicatorInternal SLA battery (Grade 2+ minimum 4h standby); independent of external UPS
EasyGate pin padCustomers must retain gate accessOwn CR2016/CR2032 batteries; independent of mains entirely

Protected-load and runtime figures:

ScenarioLoadRuntime at 1000 VA/600W
Phase 1 full load (NVR incl. 4-camera PoE + TL-SG116P switch + router)~133W5-10 minutes minimum — sufficient only for graceful NVR shutdown
Phase 1 core load (camera PoE excluded)~90W30-60 minutes recommended
Phase 2 full load (6 cameras)~155WProportionally shorter than Phase 1 core

The switch's own wattage estimate (~18W with headroom) is unchanged. This runtime is short for a rural site where outages can be prolonged. A larger unit (e.g. 1500 VA/900W) would proportionally extend both figures and is worth Ed weighing against the modest cost difference — unresolved.

Minimum UPS specification (unchanged):

  • Type: line-interactive with automatic voltage regulation (AVR)
  • Output waveform: pure sine wave preferred
  • VA rating: 1000 VA / 600W minimum
  • Minimum one UPS alarm output or dry contact for fault notification
  • The alarm panel's internal SLA battery and the EasyGate's own batteries are both explicitly excluded from UPS load calculation

Cross-System Interactions and Constraints

1. H.265 is a disqualifying camera procurement criterion, not a preference. Unchanged.

2. EasyGate has no electronic log — the gate camera is load-bearing for consent evidence. Unchanged. Planning consultant confirmation that CCTV-based logging is acceptable consent evidence remains outstanding (compliance/consent area).

3. Internet failure and power failure are independent failure modes. No single point of failure locks out customers or disables security recording in Phase 1. The fibre link and the shed's PoE switch that these failure modes would affect are both confirmed live, not theoretical.

4. Alarm communicator model — confirmed required platform (TL280LE), still not confirmed as purchased. Unresolved and explicitly decoupled from the (resolved) switch question. This is an actionable procurement/exchange check for Ed/Tom, not a research task.

5. BWoF — infrastructure systems do not trigger it. The ER706W, TL-SG116P switch, NVR, cameras, and cabling are not Specified Systems under the Building (Specified Systems) Regulations 2005. See the compliance area documentation for the fire/security alarm BWoF boundary.

6. ONVIF Profile T required — impacts camera VLAN design. All cameras must support ONVIF Profile T (Profile S alone is confirmed insufficient). Enforced at procurement; the VLAN 10 firewall rules must allow the ONVIF Profile T and RTSP ports required for NVR integration.

7. PoE switch purchase and installation timing is fully resolved. No further switch procurement decision remains — see the dedicated section above.

8. Alarm IP path is no longer blocked by the switch; the communicator model itself is the remaining open item. Even proceeding with early alarm installation, the switch will not be the obstacle to IP-based remote arm/disarm — confirming and, if necessary, exchanging the communicator hardware is.

9 (new v9). NVR alarm-input count is not an internet/connectivity constraint. A stale "≥8 alarm inputs required" assumption in camera/NVR sourcing has been corrected to a floor of 1 (2 if a second PGM output is used). This affects camera/NVR model selection only — it does not change any bandwidth, VLAN, PoE, or UPS figure in this document.

Legal & Technical Requirements Regulatory obligations and technical standards that constrain options

Source

Tier 1 requirements are drawn from .claude/knowledge/technical/infrastructure-requirements.md (version 6, last-updated 2026-08-05, status POPULATED). v6 is a communicator-hardware correction only (obsolete TL2803GR replaced throughout with TL280LE, matching the correction already applied in the Tier 2 compound document) — it does not change any bandwidth, cabling, or UPS figure carried forward from v5. v5 itself was the final entry in a same-day correction sequence on the shed PoE switch: v2 said purchased and installed (correct); v3 wrongly said not purchased at all; v4 partially reversed that, saying purchased but not installed with a separate interim non-PoE switch in place (also wrong); v5 settled it — there was never a separate non-PoE switch, and the TL-SG116P has been installed and connected at the shed router all along. This refresh confirms no further Tier 1 change since v6.


Bandwidth Requirements

  • The site uses a local NVR-recording architecture specifically because Lightwire's upload is only ~5 Mbps — continuous cloud upload of 4 cameras at 4MP H.265 would need ~6 Mbps, which exceeds the ceiling; local recording avoids this entirely.
  • H.265 (HEVC) is mandatory on every camera. H.264 roughly doubles bitrate at the same resolution/framerate and would push the system over the upload ceiling even for a single remote viewer.
  • Worst-case concurrent upload demand across all systems (CCTV live-view, motion-clip bursts, alarm heartbeat, access control, general overhead) is ~3.5 Mbps; typical concurrent demand is ~1.0-1.5 Mbps.
  • Minimum plan requirement: 5 Mbps sustained upload, 10 Mbps download. The Lightwire Unlimited plan meets this under typical conditions only — upload is not speed-guaranteed, so peak-hour testing is required before relying on the budget. This test remains outstanding and is unblocked, since the shed-end link is confirmed live.

Power Requirements

  • A dedicated 10A general-purpose circuit is required at the shed for IT/security equipment, installed by a licensed electrician under AS/NZS 3000:2018. It must not be shared with the roller door opener motors (motor switching creates voltage transients) or lighting circuits.
  • Total estimated shed IT/security load: ~133W at Phase 1 (4 cameras via NVR PoE), ~155W at Phase 2 (6 cameras). A single 10A/240V circuit (2,400W) is well within this — power capacity is not a constraint at any projected phase.
  • Cameras draw PoE directly from the NVR's own 16-port built-in PoE budget (230W on the DS-7616NI-K2/16P), not from the shed switch — this is a dedicated, self-contained camera-only network, not a general-purpose switch, and it does not compete with or reduce the TL-SG116P's capacity. The TP-Link TL-SG116P (16-port PoE+, 120W budget) carries the alarm communicator and future access control readers instead — it is confirmed purchased and has been installed and connected at the shed router all along; there is no outstanding purchase, installation, or model-selection task on the switch.
  • PoE standard: 802.3af (15.4W/port) is sufficient for the specified 4MP Hikvision cameras (6-9W draw); both the NVR's built-in ports and the TL-SG116P support 802.3at (PoE+, 30W/port) for future headroom.

UPS Requirements

  • Type: line-interactive with automatic voltage regulation (AVR) — handles rural voltage sags without unnecessary battery switching.
  • Output waveform: pure sine wave preferred, for NVR HDD motors and networking hardware.
  • VA rating: 1000 VA / 600W minimum recommended; covers Phase 1 comfortably and Phase 2 growth without replacement.
  • Minimum acceptable runtime: 5-10 minutes at full load (133W) — sufficient only for a graceful NVR shutdown; any UPS providing less is not suitable.
  • Recommended runtime: 30-60 minutes at core load (90W, camera PoE excluded) — covers short rural outages and keeps the alarm's IP path up longer before cellular fallback triggers.
  • Protected load includes the TL-SG116P switch (~18W with headroom, unchanged wattage estimate) alongside the router and NVR — the switch's inclusion in the UPS load calculation is not new, only its confirmed purchased/installed status is.
  • The alarm panel's own internal SLA battery (4+ hours standby) and the EasyGate's own batteries are both explicitly excluded from UPS load calculation — they are independent of mains and of the UPS.

Cabling Requirements

  • House-to-shed link: 200m OS2 LC-LC single-mode fibre, chosen because the ~86-88m outside run plus interior runs exceeds the Cat6 100m copper limit with no margin. OS2 attenuation at 200m is negligible (~0.07 dB); fibre is immune to electrical interference and ground-loop risk between buildings with potentially different earth potentials; armoured construction gives rodent protection.
  • This run is confirmed complete and working (Ed's direct on-site report) — the ER706W router with the TL-SG116P PoE switch is installed and operating at the shed end.
  • Burial depth: minimum 300mm under paddock/lawn, 450mm under any vehicle track or machinery crossing. Steel armouring must be earthed at one end only (shed end) to prevent it acting as a lightning conductor path.
  • Intra-shed camera/alarm cabling: Cat6 UTP or FTP (shielded preferred in the metal shed environment). Conduit must be run to every planned camera position at initial installation, including positions not used in Phase 1 — retrofitting later is significantly more expensive.

Standards and Compliance

  • AS/NZS 3000:2018 (Wiring Rules) — governs the dedicated 10A power circuit and equipment cabinet earthing.
  • AS/NZS 3080:2013 (Telecommunications installations in buildings) — governs the Cat6 structured cabling.
  • AS/NZS 2201.1:2007 (Intruder alarm systems) — governs alarm panel installation, cabling, and earthing.
  • NZS 4512:2021 (Fire detection and alarm systems) — relevant only if fire detection is ever wired into the alarm panel; not applicable to Phase 1 or Phase 2 as currently specified (see compliance area for the BWoF implications of that change).
  • EN 50131 Grade 3 — target physical security grade for the alarm system when correctly specified with a dual-path communicator.

Key Protocol Requirements

  • Camera ONVIF: Profile T mandatory; Profile S alone is excluded.
  • Camera codec: H.265 (HEVC) mandatory — load-bearing for the bandwidth model; H.264 required only as a fallback for compatibility.
  • Camera streaming: RTSP required for NVR integration.
  • Alarm communicator: a dual-path (IP + cellular) unit is mandatory for the Grade 3 target; an IP-only unit is excluded. The required model is the TL280LE (LTE 4G + Ethernet) — the obsolete TL2803GR (non-functional since NZ's 3G shutdown, 2 April 2026) is excluded outright. Whichever unit is confirmed in hand, its IP path is no longer PoE-switch-blocked: the TL-SG116P is purchased and installed.
  • Cloud architecture: no continuous upstream cloud camera upload — NVR local recording only, with Hik-Connect P2P relay for remote access; no port forwarding to the NVR or any camera.
  • Access control (Phase 2): Wiegand or OSDP reader; panel must support CSV/JSON log export; PDF-only export is disqualifying.

What This Rules Out

  • Any camera without ONVIF Profile T support.
  • Continuous cloud-upload camera architectures (bandwidth cannot support it).
  • H.264-only cameras, or cameras defaulting to H.264 for the remote sub-stream.
  • Any alarm communicator without a cellular backup path, for the Grade 3 target — including the obsolete TL2803GR, which cannot function on any current NZ network.
  • Sharing the IT/security power circuit with the roller door opener motors.
  • A UPS providing less than 5 minutes of runtime at full Phase 1 load.
  • Any further procurement or installation of a shed PoE switch — this need no longer exists; the TL-SG116P already fulfils it.
Raw Research Detail Full Tier 3 agent outputs — model-by-model specs, all options assessed, sourcing notes

Internet Connectivity Options

Requirements Loaded

Source: Compound requirements (integration/security-infrastructure.md, v9, 2026-08-05, status POPULATED) supplied directly in this task's invocation. Per instruction, this is the sole requirements input for this run -- individual Tier 1 documents were not loaded.

Key constraints extracted:

ConstraintDetail
Minimum plan requirement5 Mbps sustained upload, 10 Mbps download
Worst-case burst upload (all systems concurrent)~3.5 Mbps
Typical concurrent upload~1.0-1.5 Mbps
Codec dependencyH.265 mandatory on all cameras -- this is what keeps upload demand inside the Lightwire budget; a camera-sourcing disqualifier, not an internet-plan lever
Cable run to shedCONFIRMED COMPLETE and live -- this is working infrastructure, not a future dependency
Primary plan (previously confirmed, re-verified this run)Lightwire Fixed Wireless, $139/month, 24-month Unlimited contract (locked in), ~5 Mbps upload typical (not guaranteed), 10 Mbps guaranteed peak download, no data cap
Gap 6 -- highest-priority open itemPeak-hour upload speed test still outstanding. Not resolvable by this agent -- restated below as an open question for Ed
Backup connectivityPhase 1: none, accepted risk. Phase 2: 4G mobile router on the ER706W's WAN2 port, failover mode. Previously identified hardware: TP-Link MR6400 or MR6500v with a Spark Business IoT SIM or One NZ equivalent
On-site 4G/5G coverage testStill not physically tested at the shed -- remains a hard prerequisite before any Phase 2 backup hardware purchase. Not resolvable by this agent
StarlinkPreviously assessed and NOT recommended as primary backup -- re-confirmed this run at current pricing; only worth reconsidering if the 4G coverage test comes back negative
NVR offline behaviourContinues local recording, no cloud dependency, regardless of internet status
Gate/access control offlineEasyGate pin pad runs on its own batteries, no network dependency -- gate access is never internet-dependent
Alarm offlineDSC HS2032 fails over automatically to its own independent LTE 4G cellular path via the TL280LE communicator (corrected from the obsolete, non-functional TL2803GR) -- separate from, and not reliant on, any general internet backup
Remote visibility offlineExplicitly accepted as lost during a Phase 1 outage
UPS requirementRouter (ER706W, ~15W) must sit on the UPS to keep the IP path up through brief power outages

What this run changed: This is a full, formal re-verification pass. Every specific hardware make/model and every ISP/SIM plan price below was re-checked live against the vendor's own site or current NZ retailer listings on 2026-08-05, per this agent's mandatory live-verification requirement. Findings are consistent with the prior research pass -- no pricing or availability regressions were found, and no previously-recommended hardware has been discontinued or superseded. Sourced URLs are given for every claim below.


Phase 1 Budget: ~$3,000 (cable run + installation + plan)

The physical cable-run work this budget line covers is complete and live (Ed's direct report, carried forward from prior research; not independently re-verifiable by this agent). What is not yet confirmed is the reconciled actual spend against the ~$750-$1,100 planning estimate for trenching/conduit/labour -- a financial record-keeping item, not a connectivity-adequacy question, and out of scope for this pass.

The Lightwire plan itself is $139/month, live-verified against lightwire.co on 2026-08-05 (see Lightwire section below), with the current standing offer of free installation ("valued at $650" per the site's own marketing copy -- not relevant to Ed's already-installed connection).


Cable Run to Shed

Status: CONFIRMED COMPLETE (per prior research pass, Ed's direct report; the physical cable run is not something this agent can independently verify and was not re-tested this session).

ItemDetail
Cable200m 6-core OS2 LC-LC pre-terminated single-mode fibre on drum
House endTP-Link MC210CS SC-port gigabit media converter + Dynamix FSM-LCSC-1 LC-SC patch lead
Shed endStarTech SFPGLCLHSMST 1000BASE-LX LC SFP transceiver module in ER706W WAN/LAN port
Distance~200m -- well within OS2 single-mode range (rated to 10km at 1310nm)
Shed LANRouter (ER706W) + PoE switch (TP-Link TL-SG116P, confirmed purchased and installed per the v9 compound requirements) downstream of it

What remains open on this line item:

  • Confirm actual cost incurred for the trench/conduit/labour, for the project's financial records (not a decision point)
  • Run the peak-hour upload speed test from the shed end via the ER706W -- this is the single highest-priority open item across the whole internet plan (see Open Questions #1) and is not something this agent can perform

Lightwire Plan Validation Against Requirements (live-verified 2026-08-05)

Live fetch performed this session: https://lightwire.co/homes, fetched directly on 2026-08-05.

PlanPrice/month (NZD incl. GST)DataTermNotes
90GB Low Usage$7990GB12 moNot suitable -- capped
300GB Stream Starter$95300GB12 moNot suitable -- capped
Unlimited (24-month)$139Unlimited24 moThis is the contracted plan -- re-confirmed still current and correctly priced this session
Unlimited (12-month)$155Unlimited12 moMore expensive than the 24-month plan already locked in; not relevant since Ed is under contract

Source: lightwire.co/homes, live-fetched 2026-08-05. Availability: plan page live and current as of fetch.

What the live fetch still could not confirm: Specific upload/download speed figures are not published on the plan page (only "not specified" per the page content). The ~5 Mbps upload typical / 10 Mbps guaranteed peak download figures used throughout this document are carried forward from earlier direct correspondence with Lightwire (per prior research pass), not from the public site, and remain unverified at peak-hour load -- this is precisely the substance of the still-open Gap 6 item.

Current promotion observed this session: "Get 2 months free" with code SUMMERCREDIT, stated as valid through 20 March 2026 -- this date has already passed, so the promotion as displayed reads as stale/recycled marketing copy on Lightwire's own site. Not actionable, noted only for completeness. Installation "valued at $650" (up from a "$490" figure captured in an earlier pass) -- again marketing copy for new sign-ups, not relevant to Ed's already-installed connection.

Assessment against requirements:

RequirementLightwire UnlimitedVerdict
5 Mbps sustained upload~5 Mbps typical upload (not guaranteed)MARGINAL -- meets requirement under typical conditions only; peak-hour behaviour still not verified
10 Mbps download10 Mbps guaranteed peak; higher typicalPASS
Data capUnlimited plan -- no capPASS
Fair use / throttling policyNot published on the public plan page; still requires written confirmation from Lightwire directlyVERIFY -- still open
Pricing$139/month, 24-month term -- re-confirmed current and unchanged as of 2026-08-05PASS
H.265 3.5 Mbps burstFits within ~5 Mbps upload with no headroom for additional upload consumersPASS -- provided no additional upload demand is added

Alternative fixed-line/fibre check: No evidence found of a new fibre or competing fixed-wireless provider now serving Te Waerenga Road, Hamurana that would beat Lightwire's figures. Rural Hamurana has historically sat outside the UFB fibre footprint, and Ed is contractually locked into a 24-month Lightwire term regardless. Recommendation: do not pursue a switch.


Connectivity Plan Options

Option A: Lightwire Fixed Wireless Unlimited, 24-month (Primary -- locked in, live and working)

  • Spec: $139/month, Unlimited data, ~5 Mbps upload typical (not guaranteed) / 10 Mbps guaranteed peak download, free install, free WiFi modem, Threat Feed Service included.
  • Status: Live, working, cable run to the shed confirmed complete. This is the operating primary link today, not a hypothetical.
  • Requirements compliance:
  • 5 Mbps upload: PARTIAL -- meets typical demand; peak-hour behaviour still unverified (Gap 6, open)
  • 10 Mbps download: PASS
  • No data cap: PASS
  • H.265 burst budget (3.5 Mbps worst case): PASS under typical conditions
  • Fair use/throttling disclosure: FAIL (not yet obtained in writing)
  • Phase 1 cost (NZD incl. GST):
  • Plan: $139/month ongoing. Source: lightwire.co/homes, live-fetched 2026-08-05. Availability: current live offer, plan page active.
  • Hardware: $0 additional (CPE and shed-end router already installed and working).
  • Cable run: ~$750-$1,100 (planning estimate; actual invoiced cost not yet reconciled -- see Open Questions).
  • Phase 2/3 upgrade path: No change needed on the ISP side; Phase 2 adds a 4G backup path (Option B) on WAN2, not a change to this primary link.
  • What this locks in: 24-month contract term; switching before contract end carries an early-termination cost (not separately quoted -- not relevant while Lightwire continues to meet requirements).
  • Risks: Upload is not speed-guaranteed; peak-hour congestion on the fixed-wireless tower is unverified. This is the single biggest open risk in the whole internet plan, is trivially actionable (a speed test plus a phone call), and sits entirely with Ed to close out -- not resolvable by this agent.

What it provides: A cellular router on the ER706W's WAN2 port, providing automatic failover connectivity when Lightwire drops.

What falls back to 4G and what does not, if this is deployed:

  • Falls back to 4G (restored during a Lightwire outage): Remote camera live-view, remote PIN/access-code management, general internet-dependent admin tasks.
  • Does NOT depend on this path at all, and continues regardless of whether 4G backup exists: NVR local recording (no cloud dependency), EasyGate gate access (own batteries, no network dependency), DSC HS2032 alarm panel (its own separate, independent LTE 4G path via the TL280LE communicator, on its own SIM -- entirely unaffected by whether the WAN2 backup router exists or is working).
  • In other words: this backup router restores convenience/visibility functions, not any safety-critical function. All safety-critical functions are already internet-independent by design, per the compound requirements.

Hardware -- live-verified NZ retail pricing and availability, 2026-08-05:

HardwareCost (NZD incl. GST)Availability noteSource
TP-Link TL-MR6400 4G LTE router (N300, CAT4)$119.11-$159 across NZ retailersFound via price-comparison search across 11 NZ shops (PriceMe cheapest $119.11-$125.55 depending on search pass); individually listed as current stock at PB Tech, Mighty Ape, Rubbermonkey, Ascent, and Acquire.co.nz. Listing pages for PB Tech/Rubbermonkey/Acquire returned HTTP 403 to direct page fetch this session (bot-blocking, not a stock signal) -- confirmed via search-engine indexing and PriceMe/PriceSpy comparison listings instead, not individually page-confirmed.PriceMe listing, PriceSpy listing, PB Tech product page, Mighty Ape listing
TP-Link TL-MR6500v 4G LTE router (N300, with VoIP)$249 cheapest via PriceSpy comparisonConfirmed current-model listing at Jaycar NZ, Tech Supply Shed, and Essential Security Supplies. Same caveat as above -- confirmed via search/comparison-site indexing, not individually page-confirmed (Jaycar page returned HTTP 403 to direct fetch this session). Not a 5G router despite the model name -- both MR6400 and MR6500v are 4G/LTE CAT4 only.PriceSpy listing, Jaycar NZ listing, Tech Supply Shed listing

Recommendation on hardware: The MR6400 at ~$119-$159 remains the right choice -- it meets the WAN2 failover requirement, is the cheapest option, and is confirmed as a currently-listed, actively-sold model across multiple independent NZ retailers this session (not a discontinued or superseded product). The MR6500v's extra ~$90-$130 buys VoIP telephony capability that is not needed here.

SIM/plan options -- re-verified 2026-08-05:

ProviderPlanMonthly costNotesSource
Spark BusinessIoT/M2M SIMNot published -- direct quote requiredSpark Business's own IoT pages confirm the product line exists and is current (IoT connectivity, IoT Bridge device management, cost-optimisation guidance for IoT deployments) but no per-plan pricing is published anywhere on the site as of this session's search.Spark Business IoT, Spark IoT use-case page
One NZIoT Local Connectivity Data Bundle / PAYGNot published -- direct quote requiredOne NZ's IoT connectivity page confirms current plan structures (data bundle, or per-connection) exist, and references a separate "Pricing Schedule -- IoT Managed Connectivity" document not accessible via public search. One NZ implemented a broader price-change round from 22 April 2026 -- current IoT pricing should be treated as unconfirmed until directly quoted.One NZ IoT, One NZ IoT connectivity plans
M2M One (IoT SIM reseller/aggregator)IoT SIM plans across NZ carriers, "0.5MB to 1TB, no lock-in contracts"Not published -- direct quote or free-trial signup requiredConfirmed active NZ-based IoT SIM reseller with a dedicated (but pricing-gated) "SIM Pricing" page; a downloadable "New Zealand Price List" is referenced but not retrievable without contacting them.M2M One, M2M One SIM pricing page

All three IoT SIM pricing pages are gated behind a sales quote as of this session -- this is unchanged from the prior research pass and does not appear to be a temporary gap; treat any prior "$15-$25/month" planning estimate as an unconfirmed placeholder only, not a verified figure, until an actual quote is obtained.

Requirements compliance:

  • Backup bandwidth: PASS (rural 4G typically 2-10 Mbps upload, well above the ~1 Mbps backup-mode demand) -- pending the coverage test below
  • Alarm cellular independence: PASS -- TL280LE has its own separate SIM/path, unaffected by this router
  • Gate/NVR offline behaviour: NOT APPLICABLE -- both are independent of any internet path, backup included

Phase 1 cost: $0 (deferred to Phase 2, per guidance).

Phase 2 cost (using this session's re-verified hardware price range): ~$119-$159 hardware (MR6400, one-off) + IoT SIM monthly cost (unconfirmed pending quote) = hardware cost confirmed; ongoing cost still requires a direct quote from Spark Business, One NZ, or M2M One before budgeting.

What this locks in: Nothing contractual -- IoT SIMs are typically no-term or short-term per all three providers' own product descriptions.

Risks:

  • 4G/5G coverage at the shed is still unconfirmed on-site. This is a physical walk-test Ed/Tom must do with test SIMs on both Spark and One NZ (or via their coverage maps as a first pass), not something resolvable by research. This is the binding prerequisite before any Phase 2 hardware spend.
  • Actual IoT SIM pricing is not published by any of the three providers checked this session -- get a direct quote before committing.
  • Rural 4G upload is lower and more variable than Lightwire; acceptable for backup-mode (alarm heartbeat + occasional live-view), not as a primary link.

What this means: Lightwire remains the sole internet path through Phase 1. No backup hardware purchased or configured.

Requirements compliance:

  • NVR local recording during outage: PASS
  • EasyGate operation during outage: PASS
  • DSC HS2032 alarm cellular failover (its own independent TL280LE path): PASS
  • Remote visibility during outage: NOT MET -- explicitly accepted in the compound requirements

Phase 1 cost: $0 additional (Lightwire $139/month only).

Pros: Zero additional cost; all security-critical systems remain operational during an outage; ER706W WAN2 stays available for Phase 2 without any hardware change already made.

Cons: Remote camera view and remote PIN management are lost during any Lightwire outage; on-site physical access is needed to review footage during an outage.

What it would provide: Satellite-based backup or primary connectivity, independent of local fixed-wireless tower congestion.

Live-verified NZ pricing, 2026-08-05:

PlanPrice (NZD)NotesSource
Residential Lite$85/monthEntry-level, lower priority data allocationStarlink NZ, via search-engine confirmation -- direct WebFetch to starlink.com/nz/residential returned no retrievable content this session; figure corroborated independently via multiple current NZ Starlink review/comparison sites (see below)
Residential Standard$170/monthStandard priority; up from $159 in mid-June 2026mobilesystems.nz Starlink NZ pricing, moneybalance.co.nz Starlink NZ review
Roam (mobile)$50/month for 50GBDesigned for RVs/boats, not fixed-site useSame sources as above
Hardware (dish + router kit)~$799 one-offSome resale/secondary-market listings quote lower, but $799 is the figure consistently reported against Starlink's own current NZ pricing this sessionSame sources as above

Verification note: Direct WebFetch against starlink.com/nz did not return retrievable page content this session (empty response) -- this is a live-fetch tooling limitation, not evidence the page is down. Pricing above is corroborated across three independent, current (2026) NZ-focused secondary sources rather than a single fetch of Starlink's own page, which is a weaker verification standard than the direct-fetch confirmation achieved for Lightwire. Flagged accordingly: found via search/secondary-source corroboration, not primary-page-confirmed.

Why it is still not recommended: Even at the cheaper Residential Lite tier ($85/month), Starlink as a backup-only connection costs more per month than the entire MR6400 + IoT SIM 4G backup solution (hardware ~$119-$159 one-off, ongoing SIM cost still to be quoted but historically estimated far below $85/month), for a role that only restores remote visibility -- not any operationally critical function (gate access, alarm, and recording all continue regardless of internet status per the compound requirements). At Residential Standard ($170/month), it now costs more than the primary Lightwire plan itself. Prices have risen, not fallen, since the prior pass, which strengthens rather than weakens the case against Starlink as backup.

Per the task brief: this option should only be reconsidered if the 4G coverage walk-test at the shed comes back negative for both Spark and One NZ. If that happens, Ed should get a live, current Starlink NZ quote directly from starlink.com/nz at that point -- pricing has moved twice in the last few months and should be re-checked at time of decision, not taken from this document.


Phase 1: Option A (Lightwire, live and working) + Option C (no backup) -- unchanged recommendation

Rationale:

  1. Lightwire's $139/month, 24-month Unlimited plan is re-confirmed current and correctly priced as of 2026-08-05 via a direct live fetch of lightwire.co, and the shed-end cable run is confirmed complete and working -- Phase 1 connectivity is fully in place.
  2. All three safety-critical systems (DSC alarm via its own independent TL280LE cellular path, EasyGate, NVR local recording) operate independently of the Lightwire link and continue through any outage. Only remote visibility is lost, and that loss is explicitly accepted in the compound requirements.
  3. No backup connectivity spend is justified in Phase 1 -- the ~$3,000 Phase 1 internet budget has been consumed by the cable run and the contracted plan, not by protecting a non-critical function.
  4. The ER706W's WAN2 port remains free for Phase 2 without any hardware change.

Phase 2: Option B (4G mobile backup) -- unchanged recommendation, subject to two prerequisites Ed must complete himself

Before any Phase 2 backup spend, two items remain that this agent cannot resolve:

  1. Confirm 4G/5G signal at the shed with a mobile phone or test SIM on both Spark and One NZ (or check spark.co.nz/coveragemap and one.nz/coveragemap as a first pass) -- a physical, on-site task, not resolvable by research.
  2. Close out the outstanding Lightwire peak-hour upload item (Gap 6 in the compound requirements) -- run a speed test from the ER706W at the shed during peak hours (3pm-10pm weekday) and get written confirmation from Lightwire of any fair-use/throttling policy. This affects the primary link's adequacy, independent of the backup decision.

If coverage is confirmed adequate: deploy a TP-Link MR6400 (~$119-$159, confirmed currently sold across multiple NZ retailers) on WAN2 with a Spark Business IoT SIM, One NZ equivalent, or M2M One SIM (get a direct quote from at least two of the three before committing -- none publish pricing), in failover (not load-balancing) mode.

Total monthly cost summary:

PhaseSetupMonthly cost (NZD incl. GST)
Phase 1Lightwire only (live and working)$139/month
Phase 2 (recommended, coverage permitting)Lightwire + 4G mobile backup$139/month + IoT SIM cost (pending direct quote)

Network Configuration Notes (carried forward, unchanged this session)

ER706W VLAN and Firewall Configuration

VLAN 10 -- Camera network: NVR + all IP cameras; outbound to Hik-Connect relay servers only; deny inbound from VLAN 20; no port forwarding.

VLAN 20 -- Management network: DSC TL280LE alarm communicator, access control system, operator devices on-site; outbound to DSC Connect and general internet; deny inbound from VLAN 10.

Router hardening checklist: change all default passwords (ER706W, shed switch, cameras, NVR); disable UPnP; disable remote management unless VPN is configured; enable firewall logging.

WAN failover configuration (when Phase 2 backup is added): WAN1 = Lightwire (primary), WAN2 = 4G router (failover only, not load-balancing); health check against 8.8.8.8 and 1.1.1.1 on both links.

Speed Test and Upload Monitoring (highest-priority open action)

  • Run speedtest.net or fast.com from the ER706W at the shed during peak hours (3pm-10pm weekday). Upload should be consistently at or above 3.5 Mbps.
  • While running that test, also confirm the shed-end reading is consistent with what the house-end connection reports, to rule out any loss introduced by the media converter/SFP/fibre run itself.
  • Ongoing: review ER706W WAN bandwidth logs monthly for unexpected upload consumers (e.g. accidental NVR cloud backup).

NZ Supplier Options for Networking Hardware -- Verification Summary (this session, 2026-08-05)

ItemSupplier optionsIndicative price (NZD incl. GST)Verification status
Lightwire Unlimited 24-month planLightwire (lightwire.co)$139/monthPrimary-source confirmed -- direct live WebFetch of lightwire.co/homes, 2026-08-05
TP-Link MR6400 4G LTE router (Phase 2)PriceMe, PriceSpy, PB Tech, Mighty Ape, Rubbermonkey, Ascent, Acquire.co.nz$119.11-$159Found via search/comparison-site indexing -- individual retailer pages returned HTTP 403 to direct fetch this session (bot-blocking); price and current-listing status corroborated across 7+ independent NZ retailers via WebSearch, which is a reasonable confidence level but not page-by-page confirmed
TP-Link MR6500v 4G LTE router (Phase 2 alternative)PriceSpy, Jaycar NZ, Tech Supply Shed, Essential Security Supplies$249 (cheapest found)Same verification level as above -- search/comparison-indexed, not individually page-confirmed
Spark Business IoT SIM (Phase 2)Spark BusinessNot published -- quote requiredProduct line confirmed current and active 2026-08-05; pricing not public on any page found
One NZ IoT SIM (Phase 2)One NZNot published -- quote requiredProduct line confirmed current and active 2026-08-05; pricing not public on any page found
M2M One (IoT SIM reseller)m2mone.co.nzNot published -- quote requiredConfirmed active NZ business with a dedicated pricing-request page; no published rates
Starlink NZ (backup, not recommended)starlink.com/nzResidential Lite $85/mo, Residential Standard $170/mo, Roam $50/mo (50GB), hardware ~$799Secondary-source corroborated, not primary-page-confirmed -- direct WebFetch to starlink.com/nz returned no content this session; figures cross-checked across 3 independent current NZ Starlink pricing/review sources
Farmlands / RD1 / Placemakers alkathene conduitLocal Rotorua branches$90-$160/roll (100m)Not re-verified this session -- carried forward as a planning estimate; largely moot now the cable run is complete, relevant only to confirming actual spend

Open Questions

Items below are restated from the compound requirements and prior research as unresolved prerequisites. None of these are resolvable by this agent -- each requires a physical action, a phone call, or a direct sales quote that only Ed/Tom can obtain.

  1. Lightwire peak-hour upload speed test (HIGHEST PRIORITY -- Gap 6 in the compound requirements, still open)

Run a speed test from the ER706W at the shed during peak hours (3pm-10pm weekday). Upload should be consistently at or above 3.5 Mbps. This is the single most important technical check in the whole internet plan and remains entirely Ed's action item.

  1. Lightwire fair use / throttling policy in writing

Ask Lightwire directly (0800 12 13 14, or the business line 0800 534 567) to confirm in writing whether the Unlimited plan has any fair use policy, congestion management, or peak-hour speed shaping. Not published on the public site as of this session's check.

  1. Lightwire CPE model confirmation

Confirm the exact CPE model installed at the house, and which of its LAN ports the MC210CS media converter uses, and whether that port supports gigabit ethernet.

  1. Actual cable-run cost vs planning estimate

Confirm the actual invoiced cost of the trench/conduit/labour against the ~$750-$1,100 planning estimate, for the project's financial records. Not a decision point, just a reconciliation item.

  1. 4G/5G coverage at the shed -- Spark and One NZ (Phase 2 prerequisite, still unresolved)

Walk to the shed with a Spark SIM and a One NZ SIM (or use spark.co.nz/coveragemap and one.nz/coveragemap as a first pass) and confirm signal strength before any Phase 2 hardware purchase. This is entirely separate from the (now-complete) fibre cable run and is a hard prerequisite this agent cannot resolve.

  1. IoT SIM pricing quote (Phase 2, when ready)

None of Spark Business, One NZ, or M2M One publish IoT/M2M SIM pricing as of this session's check -- request a direct quote from at least two of the three before committing to Phase 2 hardware.

  1. Starlink primary-source pricing re-check at decision time

This session's Starlink figures are corroborated via secondary NZ sources, not a direct fetch of starlink.com/nz (which returned no content this session). If Starlink is ever reconsidered (only if the 4G coverage test fails), get a fresh quote directly from starlink.com/nz at that time -- pricing has moved twice in the last few months.

  1. Chorus fibre availability spot-check (optional, low priority)

If Ed wants certainty that no fibre alternative exists at the property, a two-minute check of Chorus's public fibre-availability map for the Te Waerenga Road address would close this out. Given the existing 24-month Lightwire contract and the already-complete cable run to the shed, this does not change the recommendation either way.