Recommendation
Actions for Ed and Tom
Tom (all on site, one visit)
- Run the LTE signal test at the alarm cabinet on Spark, One NZ and 2degrees. Method is in options.md. It decides the alarm SIM and whether a 4G backup link can work.
- Run the weekday peak-hour upload test (3pm to 10pm) on the same visit. Pass is at least 3.5 Mbps sustained.
- Check the TL-SG116P label or admin page. No admin page confirms it is unmanaged.
- Test whether the ER706W can put one LAN port on its own subnet. It costs nothing.
- Measure the gate distance from the cabinet and the cable run to each boat bay. Photograph the gate motor. The boat-bay openers are Grifco LS-Drive with BBU (Ed, 2026-10-15); check the LS-Drive manual for its open input.
- Confirm the Lightwire CPE model at the house and that the port feeding the MC210CS is gigabit.
- Start an outage log for Lightwire now. It supplies the 4G backup trigger.
Ed
- Ask Lightwire in writing for public IP or carrier-grade NAT, and the fair-use policy. Call 0800 12 13 14 or 0800 534 567 (numbers carried forward, not re-checked).
- Ask the chosen carrier in writing whether prepay allows a machine-to-machine device. Get one IoT SIM quote from One NZ (iot.nz@one.nz) or M2M One.
- Rule on the 4G backup trigger: more than one outage of an hour or more in a quarter, or any outage that blocks a customer.
- Rule on segmentation. The recommendation is flat network, no new switch.
- Opener fallback: resolved 2026-10-15 by Ed. The openers are Grifco LS-Drive with a BBU. Rule on the manual release alone only if the BBU proves too short (hold time unconfirmed).
- Approve a house-end UPS (about $150 to $300) and the Phase 1 envelope of about $13,000 to $20,000 for alarm, access control, UPS and cabling.
- Reconcile the invoiced cable run cost against the $750 to $1,100 estimate. This is a records item.
At a glance
| Topic | Recommended | Cost (NZD) | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Internet | Option A: Lightwire Unlimited, 24 months | $139 a month | Live. Peak upload unmeasured. |
| Alarm backup path | Option B: alarm LTE SIM | $96 to $276 a year | Blocked by the LTE test |
| Whole-site backup | Option C: 4G backup link, only on a trigger | $0 now. About $158 once plus $276 to $336 a year if triggered. | Not bought in Phase 1 |
| Network switch | Keep the TL-SG116P, unmanaged | $0 | Settled for Phase 1 |
| House-end UPS | Small UPS, 20 to 30W load | About $150 to $300 | No model chosen |
| Power and cabling for access control and alarm | Requirements from Tier 1 and Tier 2 | Part of the $13,000 to $20,000 envelope | Quotes needed |
What we recommend
- Lightwire stays. Lightwire Unlimited is $139 a month on a 24-month term and the fibre run to the shed is live. No competing fixed line exists at Te Waerenga Road. See Option A.
- Alarm LTE SIM. The DSC TL280LEE/TL280LE(R)E%20-%20PowerSeries%20Neo%20LTE/HSPA/Internet%20Cellular/Dual%20Path%20Alarm%20Communicator/2639) needs its own SIM. Prepay costs $96 to $276 a year (2degrees, One NZ, Spark). Pick the carrier with the best test result. The signal is untested. See Option B.
- 4G backup link only on a trigger. The alarm already reports over its own LTE path. A 4G link only restores remote PIN edits, log export and remote camera view. Buy the TP-Link TL-MR6400 (about $158) after the LTE test passes and the trigger is met. See Option C.
- Switch stays. Keep the TL-SG116P unmanaged for Phase 1. Cameras are already isolated on the NVR's own PoE ports. Put the communicator and controller on a separate ER706W LAN port. The earlier VLAN plan is withdrawn. If Ed rules segmentation is required, the TL-SG108PE is the cheapest managed step.
- House-end UPS. Remote PIN edits are now a Phase 1 function. A house power cut drops the shed's internet while the shed UPS holds. Fit a small UPS for the radio, CPE and MC210CS.
Power and cabling for Phase 1 access control and alarm
Tier 3 does not price these. Figures are Tier 2 planning estimates, excluding GST. Details are in integration.md.
| Need | Requirement | Planning estimate |
|---|---|---|
| Shed UPS | Line-interactive, pure sine, at least 1000 VA / 600W, for about 192W. At least 10 minutes, target 30 minutes or more. | $450 to $1,000 with alarm battery upgrade |
| Controller battery | 40 to 65 Ah for 24 hours (8 readers, gate unit, egress and panic circuits). A shorter reader standby is Ed's call. | Inside the access controller line, $3,500 to $7,500 |
| Alarm panel battery | Real standby current may exceed 24 hours on the stock 7 Ah battery. Fit a larger one if so. | Inside the UPS line above |
| Opener battery backup (6 boat bays) | Each opener needs its own battery so the panic button can open the door in a power cut. The manual inside release stays on every door. | $600 to $1,800. BBUs are already fitted to the Grifco LS-Drive openers (Ed, 2026-10-15), so this may fall to $0. |
| Boat-bay cabling | 24 home-run cables. About 290 m of Cat6 FTP, 290 m of 6-core and 580 m of 4-core at an assumed 40 m average run. | $1,500 to $4,000 with the gate run |
| Gate cabling | Cat6 PoE within about 90 m. Beyond that, armoured fibre and a media converter. | Fibre adds about $1,500 to $4,000 |
| Dedicated circuit | 10A circuit with RCD for the cabinet, certified by an electrician. | $500 to $1,200 |
What is still to decide
- LTE result per carrier, and so the alarm SIM and whether Option C is viable.
- Peak-hour upload result. Below 3.5 Mbps, limit remote view to the sub-stream and move clip uploads off-peak.
- Lightwire answers on public IP or carrier-grade NAT. If NAT-ed, a vendor relay is the only remote PIN route.
- Whether the NZ TL280LE unit has a bundled SIM or an open slot, and its LTE bands including band 28.
source-alarmsowns the unit. - Segmentation: yes or no (Ed).
- Reader standby time: 24 hours or shorter (Ed).
- Opener fallback: resolved 2026-10-15 (Grifco LS-Drive with BBU). Only needed if the BBU proves too short (Ed).
- The 4G backup trigger (Ed).
- House-end UPS model.
- Gate distance, which sets Cat6 or fibre.
Decisions already taken
| Date | Decision | Effect on infrastructure |
|---|---|---|
| 2026-03-31 | Run fibre cable from house to shed. Lightwire is the primary provider. | Cable laid at Easter 2026. Live. |
| 2026-10-15 | Replace the EasyGate keypad in Phase 1 with a remotely programmable controller that logs every entry and exit. | Remote PIN edits need the internet. Controller and alarm panel need power cover. |
| 2026-10-15 | Alarm moves to Phase 1, integrated with access control. | Alarm LTE SIM and communicator are Phase 1. |
| 2026-10-15 | Only the 6 boat bays get keypads and the alarm. The 6 small bays are padlock only. | Cabling covers 6 bays, not 12. |
| 2026-10-15 | The inside panic button unlocks and opens the boat bay door. | Each opener needs battery backup. |
| 2026-10-15 | The gate stays shut on power loss, with a manual release and a separate walk-through exit. | Gate hardware is fail-secure. |
Outstanding assignments
- Ed: connect and confirm the internet cable to the shed. The cable is live, so this assignment looks stale. Ed to close it.
- Ed: source a new pin-pad with audit logging. The assignment says Phase 2, but the 2026-10-15 decision moved it to Phase 1. Ed to update.
- Ed: research gate default and auto closure. The 2026-10-15 decision fixes the default as shut on power loss. Motor research continues.
- Jenny: update the FMG classification before launch. The insurer's alarm grade drives the dual-path requirement.
Blocked by
No open item in context/open-items.md blocks this area. Three affect it.
- Planning consultant engagement (OPEN since 2026-08-01 target). It sets the order of the Rotorua Lakes Council approach on door hardware and the panic-open function.
- Loan covenant documents (OPEN, Jenny). They cap the Phase 1 spend.
- Insurer quote (closed 2026-04-01 for the $900 farm cover). The alarm grade the insurer wants is still not known.
Options Considered Vendor and product options with costs and trade-offs
Source: working/internet/source-internet.md, run 2026-10-15 against compound requirements v11. All prices are NZD including GST and were checked 2026-10-15 unless a row says otherwise. Recommended: Option A now, Option B after the LTE test, Option C only on a trigger.
Phase 1 internet budget
| Item | Cost | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Cable run and fibre hardware | Spent. Invoiced actual not reconciled against the $750 to $1,100 estimate. | Live (Ed's report, not re-verified) |
| Lightwire Unlimited, 24 months | $139 a month ($1,668 a year) | Live |
| Alarm SIM | $96 to $276 a year | Needs the LTE test first |
| House-end UPS | About $150 to $300 | Recommended now |
| 4G backup link | $0 in Phase 1 | Conditional |
Cable run to shed
Complete and live.
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Cable | 200 m 6-core OS2 LC-LC pre-terminated single-mode fibre |
| House end | TP-Link MC210CS media converter and Dynamix FSM-LCSC-1 patch lead |
| Shed end | StarTech SFPGLCLHSMST 1000BASE-LX SFP in the ER706W |
| Range | About 200 m. OS2 is rated to 10 km. |
| Shed LAN | ER706W router, then TL-SG116P PoE switch |
- The fibre does not reach the gate. Cat6 PoE works to about 90 m. Beyond that the gate needs armoured fibre and a media converter. That cost sits with access control.
- The house end has no UPS (see House-end UPS).
Lightwire plan
Source: lightwire.co/homes, page live 2026-10-15.
| Plan | Price a month | Data | Term | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90GB Low Usage | $79 | 90GB, then $0.50/GB | 12 months | Lightwire |
| 300GB Stream Starter | $95 | 300GB, then $0.50/GB | 12 months | Lightwire |
| Unlimited (Ed's plan) | $139 | Unlimited | 24 months | Lightwire |
| Unlimited | $155 | Unlimited | 12 months | Lightwire |
- The page publishes no speeds, no fair-use policy and no word on public IP or carrier-grade NAT.
- The 5 Mbps up and 10 Mbps down figures come from earlier correspondence with Lightwire, not the public site.
- The "free install" value on the site does not apply to Ed's live connection.
| Requirement | Verdict |
|---|---|
| 5 Mbps up | PARTIAL. Typical figure only. Peak unmeasured. |
| 10 Mbps down | PASS |
| No data cap | PASS |
| Worst-case 3.7 Mbps up fits | PASS on the typical figure, about 1.3 Mbps spare. Unproven at peak. |
| Fair-use policy | OPEN. Get it in writing. |
| Public IP or CGNAT | OPEN. Decides the remote PIN route. |
Connectivity options
Option A -- Lightwire Unlimited
Primary link. Live.
- Cost: $139 a month. Hardware $0.
- Compliance: download PASS. Upload PARTIAL. Fair use and NAT OPEN.
- Locks in: the 24-month term. Do not switch.
- Risk: peak-hour upload is the biggest unknown. Lightwire is also the only path for remote PIN edits.
| Item | Qty | Unit price (NZD) | Total | Availability | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lightwire Unlimited, 24-month | 1 | $139 a month | $1,668 a year | Page live and current 2026-10-15 | Lightwire ↗ |
Option B -- Alarm LTE SIM
Phase 1. Carries alarm reports, panic, AC loss and tamper alerts when Lightwire is down. It has its own SIM and does not depend on Option C. It does not carry general internet.
Facts and gaps for the communicator
- DSC lists the TL280LEE/TL280LE(R)E%20-%20PowerSeries%20Neo%20LTE/HSPA/Internet%20Cellular/Dual%20Path%20Alarm%20Communicator/2639) as "SIM Card (included)" for North America and names only Bell, Rogers and AT&T variants. It lists no LTE bands and no NZ carrier.
- US resellers say the AT&T variant works only with AT&T (Alarm System Store). A bundled-SIM unit is the wrong unit for NZ.
- Search found no NZ price and no NZ distributor. A Swedish listing shows an EU variant (Ahlsell). It is a lead, not a confirmation.
source-alarmsowns the unit and its price. - Whether the EU unit covers band 28 (700 MHz), which rural NZ coverage leans on, is unverified. Ask the installer for the band list.
SIM plan choices. The panel sends very little data. The monthly volume is unverified.
| Item | Qty | Unit price (NZD) | Total | Availability | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2degrees prepay, Monthly $8 | 1 | $8 a month | $96 a year | Page live 2026-10-15. Data amount not shown. Rural coverage weakest of the three (recall, unverified). | 2degrees prepay ↗ |
| One NZ prepay, Rollover Small | 1 | $18 a month | $216 a year | Price from 22 April 2026. Data amount and expiry not shown. | One NZ plan changes ↗ |
| Spark prepaid Value Pack $18 | 1 | $18 a month | $216 a year | 1GB, 100 minutes, unlimited texts, rollover. The 5GB bonus applies only to new customers who port a number. | Spark prepaid ↗ |
| Spark prepaid Value Pack $23 | 1 | $23 a month | $276 a year | 2GB rollover. Headroom. | Spark prepaid ↗ |
| One NZ IoT Data Bundle or Pay As You Go | 1 | Not published | Not published | Prices exclude GST. No minimum term stated. Quote via iot.nz@one.nz. | One NZ IoT plans ↗ |
| Spark Business IoT | 1 | Not published | Not published | Quote only. Carried forward from 2026-08-05, not re-fetched. | Spark Business IoT ↗ |
| M2M One (NZ reseller) | 1 | Not published for NZ | Not published for NZ | NZ pricing gated. Its Australian list shows about A$1.47 to A$7.50 a SIM a month. That is a hint, not an NZ price. | M2M One NZ ↗, AU list ↗ |
| External antenna (if signal is weak) | 1 | UNVERIFIED | UNVERIFIED | Price at sourcing | No source in the working file |
Prepay risks for an unattended alarm
- The plan lapses if credit runs out. Set auto top-up on a Max Storage card and put the renewal date in Tom's calendar.
- Prepay terms may bar machine-to-machine use. Unverified. Ask the carrier in writing before buying.
- A prepay SIM has no business support if the panel stops reporting.
Fit. The Tier 2 estimate of $15 to $25 a month ($180 to $300 a year) matches One NZ or Spark prepay. 2degrees costs less only if the signal test passes on it. An IoT SIM could cost less again and has support. Get one quote.
Compliance. Dual-path reporting passes if the LTE test passes. It fails if the test fails. Own SIM: PASS. Locks in: nothing contractual on prepay.
LTE signal test at the shed (Tom)
One test decides the alarm path (Option B) and whether Option C works. Run it with the peak-hour Lightwire upload test.
- Map check, no visit. Look up the address on the Spark, One NZ and 2degrees coverage maps. A map shows predicted signal, not measured.
- Get a phone on each network. Borrow phones or buy the cheapest prepay SIM from each carrier. The winning carrier's SIM becomes the alarm SIM, so the test SIM is not wasted.
- Test at the cabinet. Stand where the TL280LE will sit, at that height, shed door shut. Steel cladding cuts signal.
- Read the signal.
- Android: Settings, About phone, SIM status, signal strength. It shows dBm.
- iPhone: field test mode may work (dial
3001#12345#). It depends on the iOS version. Unverified.
- Record per carrier: signal strength in dBm, whether the phone shows 4G or LTE (not 3G), and a speed test.
- Repeat at a weekday peak time (3pm to 10pm) and at a quiet time.
- Read the result with these rule-of-thumb bands (unverified for this unit):
| Reading (RSRP) | Meaning | Action |
|---|---|---|
| -95 dBm or stronger | Good | Fit the communicator at the cabinet. Option C is viable. |
| -95 to -105 dBm | Usable | Fit it. Test again after install. Consider an external antenna. |
| -105 to -115 dBm | Weak | External antenna on the communicator. Option C is doubtful. |
| Weaker than -115 dBm, or 3G only | Fail on that carrier | Try the next carrier. If all fail, Lightwire only: no dual-path and no Option C. Starlink, or a local siren plus a monitoring decision, follows (Ed). |
- Send the table to the installer with the carrier ranking so they confirm the SIM and antenna.
Option C -- 4G backup link
Phase 2, only on a trigger. The ER706W WAN2 port stays free until then.
Buy when both hold:
- The LTE test passes.
- Either the router log shows more than one outage of an hour or more in a quarter, or an outage blocks a customer from getting access.
For. Remote PIN add, change and revoke is a Phase 1 function. In an outage Tom and Ed cannot add a customer, revoke a PIN or export a log. Remote camera view is also lost. Cost is low.
Against. Nothing safety-critical depends on it. Doors, recording, alarm and panic run without internet. The alarm has its own LTE path. Tom can edit PINs on site. Nobody knows how often Lightwire drops.
| System | Lightwire outage, with Option C | Without Option C |
|---|---|---|
| Remote PIN add, change, revoke | Works over 4G | Lost |
| Log export, event push | Works over 4G | Lost |
| Remote camera view | Works, sub-stream only | Lost |
| Door and gate PINs | Work locally | Work locally |
| NVR recording | Works locally | Works locally |
| Alarm, panic, AC-loss and tamper alerts | Alarm's own LTE SIM | Same |
Hardware
| Item | Qty | Unit price (NZD) | Total | Availability | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TP-Link TL-MR6400 4G LTE router (N300, Cat4). Recommended. | 1 | $158 at PB Tech. Three-month range $139 to $159. Two other shops at $159 and $205.50. | $158 | PB Tech shown in stock on PriceSpy, fetched 2026-10-15. Not page-confirmed at the retailer (PB Tech returns 403). | PriceSpy listing ↗, PB Tech ↗ |
| TP-Link ER706W-4G (replaces the ER706W, 4G modem built in) | 1 | $630.19 at Comsys | $630.19 | Comsys: out of stock 2026-10-15, 2 to 4 weeks | Comsys ↗ |
| TP-Link ER706W-4G | 1 | $647.99 at PB Tech | $647.99 | "Only 3 left" per search. Found via search, not page-confirmed. | PB Tech ↗ |
- The ER706W-4G costs about four times as much for the same job and is out of stock. Use the MR6400 on WAN2. It sits behind the ER706W's NAT, which is fine for failover.
- Discontinuation check: TP-Link's end-of-life table lists MR6400 v1 to v3 only (last October 2019). TP-Link released v5.20 firmware in July 2024. See the Omada bulletin and the MR6400 v5.20 download page. Check the hardware version on the box is v5.
Backup SIM. One camera sub-stream at 0.5 to 1.0 Mbps uses roughly 225 to 450 MB an hour (arithmetic, not measured). Block camera streams on WAN2 with a firewall rule. Use a different carrier from the alarm SIM if both pass the test, so one network outage cannot take out both paths.
| Item | Qty | Unit price (NZD) | Total | Availability | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spark prepaid, 2GB rollover | 1 | $23 a month | $276 a year | Page live 2026-10-15 | Spark prepaid ↗ |
| Spark prepaid, 3GB rollover | 1 | $28 a month | $336 a year | Same page | Spark prepaid ↗ |
| Spark prepaid, 4.5GB rollover | 1 | $40 a month | $480 a year | Same page | Spark prepaid ↗ |
| One NZ prepay, Rollover Medium | 1 | $23 a month | $276 a year | Data amount not shown | One NZ plan changes ↗ |
| 2degrees prepay, Monthly $25 | 1 | $25 a month | $300 a year | Data amount not shown | 2degrees prepay ↗ |
| IoT SIM (One NZ, Spark Business, M2M One) | 1 | Quote | Quote | See the Option B table | One NZ IoT ↗ |
Phase 2 cost: $158 once plus $276 to $336 a year. Locks in: nothing. Risk: rural 4G upload is lower and more variable than Lightwire. Acceptable as failover, not as a primary link.
Option D -- Starlink
Fallback only. Not recommended. Use only if the LTE test fails on every carrier. The Starlink NZ site returned no content to the research agent, so prices come from secondary sources. Re-quote at starlink.com/nz with the address first.
| Item | Qty | Unit price (NZD) | Total | Availability | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Residential Standard | 1 | $170 a month (up from $159 in mid-June 2026) | $2,040 a year | Secondary sources, Aug/Sept 2026 | Budget Seniors ↗, Moneybalance ↗ |
| Residential Lite | 1 | $85 a month | $1,020 a year | Carried forward from 2026-08-05, not re-confirmed | Starlink NZ ↗ |
| Hardware | 1 | About $799 | About $799 | Rural free-hardware or discount offers exist | Budget Seniors ↗, Farmers Weekly ↗ |
- Standard costs more than Lightwire ($139).
- Starlink restores only the remote functions. It gives the alarm no second path.
House-end UPS
- The Lightwire radio, CPE and MC210CS sit at the house with no UPS. A house power cut kills the shed's internet while the shed UPS holds.
- The alarm is unaffected. Remote PIN edits and camera view are lost.
- Size: 20 to 30W load. Tier 2 estimate: $150 to $300.
| Item | Qty | Unit price (NZD) | Total | Availability | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| House-end UPS, 20 to 30W load | 1 | $150 to $300 (estimate) | $150 to $300 | UNVERIFIED. No model chosen. Live-check one at purchase. | No source in the working file |
Network layout and the switch
Is the TL-SG116P unmanaged? Almost certainly. Retailer data sheets list it as Unmanaged, plug-and-play, 16 PoE+ ports, 120W budget (MyITHub, PB Tech). TP-Link's own page could not be fetched. A switch with no admin page confirms it. Tom checks.
| Item | Qty | Unit price (NZD) | Total | Availability | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TP-Link TL-SG116P (installed, kept) | 1 | $217.98 to $243 in search snapshots | Already bought | Found via search. PB Tech page returns 403, not page-confirmed. | PB Tech ↗ |
- The listings name an "Isolation Mode" and a "Priority Mode". Isolation Mode normally stops downstream ports talking to each other. Which ports it covers is unverified. Check the manual.
- The SG116P budget is 120W. Four cameras draw about 32W. The gate unit and any PoE readers add to it.
source-access-controlmust state their draw.
Phase 1 needs no segmentation.
- Cameras are already isolated on the NVR's own PoE ports.
- The only gain is keeping the communicator and controller away from other shed devices. With no guest Wi-Fi and no third-party devices, the risk is small.
- The earlier VLAN 10 and VLAN 20 plan assumed a managed switch. It is withdrawn.
Phase 1 layout, no new hardware
- NVR uplink to one ER706W LAN port.
- Communicator and controller to a separate ER706W LAN port, not through the NVR.
- Test whether the ER706W can give that port its own subnet. Forum posts on the older TL-R605 say no. Posts on the ER706W conflict. Unconfirmed.
- If it cannot, run one flat network with strong unique passwords, no port forwarding, UPnP off and the firewall rules below.
If Ed rules segmentation is required. The ER706W supports 802.1Q (PB Tech spec sheet via search).
| Item | Qty | Unit price (NZD) | Total | Availability | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TP-Link TL-SG108PE, 8-port Easy Smart, 4 PoE ports, 55W. Cheapest managed step. | 1 | $126.15 at Comsys. About $113 at PB Tech per search. | $126.15 | Comsys in stock 2026-10-15. Page shows a stray "45" port count in its specs. Confirm. | Comsys ↗ |
| TP-Link Omada SG2210P, 8-port PoE+ smart. Not needed with an NVR. | 1 | $243.03 at Comsys | $243.03 | In stock 2026-10-15. PoE budget 53W or 61W, sources conflict. | Comsys ↗ |
| TP-Link Omada SG2218P, 16-port PoE+, 150W. Replaces the SG116P. Phase 3 only. | 1 | $459 at PB Tech. Comsys shows $492.19 on order and an older $411.69 out of stock. | $459 | PB Tech: found via search, not page-confirmed. Comsys: conflicting listings. | PB Tech ↗, Comsys ↗ |
Firewall rules (ER706W). No port forwarding. UPnP off. WAN remote management off. Logging on. Updates between midnight and 8am. Change every default password (router, switch, cameras, NVR, controller). Block camera streams on WAN2.
Remote access for the controller
- Public IP from Lightwire: vendor relay or an outbound-only VPN. Still no port forward.
- Carrier-grade NAT: vendor relay only. The ER706W supports WireGuard and OpenVPN, but a VPN into a NAT-ed site needs an outside server.
Offline behaviour
| System | Lightwire down | Lightwire and house power down |
|---|---|---|
| Gate and shed door PINs | Work. Events log locally. | Work on the controller battery. |
| Boat-bay readers and opener sequences | Work locally | Readers work on the controller battery. Opener needs its own backup. |
| NVR and cameras | Record | Record while the shed UPS lasts (target 30 to 60 min at 149W) |
| Alarm arm, disarm, re-arm | Work | Work on the panel battery |
| Alarm reports and panic alert | Go over LTE | Go over LTE while the panel battery lasts |
| Remote PIN edits, log export | Lost (Option C restores) | Lost |
| Remote camera view | Lost (Option C restores, sub-stream only) | Lost |
If the LTE test fails on every carrier, the alarm has no second path.
Recommended setup
Phase 1
- Keep Lightwire Unlimited, 24 months (Option A).
- Run the LTE test. Pick the strongest carrier. Prepay at $96 to $276 a year is enough to start (Option B). Get one IoT quote.
- Fit a house-end UPS.
- Keep the TL-SG116P. Flat network, firewall rules, communicator and controller on a separate router port.
- No 4G backup yet.
Phase 2, if the trigger is met. Buy the TL-MR6400 and a prepay SIM on a different carrier from the alarm. Run it in failover on WAN2 (Option C).
WAN failover settings. WAN1 is Lightwire. WAN2 is the 4G router, failover only. Health checks use 8.8.8.8 and 1.1.1.1 on both links.
Monitoring
- Run speedtest.net or fast.com from the shed during weekday peak. Upload should hold at or above 3.5 Mbps.
- Compare the shed reading with the house reading. A gap points at the media converter, SFP or fibre.
- Review the router's WAN bandwidth log monthly for upload consumers that should not exist.
- Keep an outage log from now. It supplies the Option C trigger.
Open questions
- Peak-hour upload test at the shed (Tom). Highest priority. Pass is 3.5 Mbps sustained.
- LTE signal test (Tom). It gates the alarm purchase and Option C.
- Lightwire in writing (Ed): public IP or carrier-grade NAT, and fair use.
- Which TL280LE unit and SIM (Tom, installer): bundled SIM or open slot, and LTE bands including band 28.
- SIM terms (Ed): machine-to-machine on prepay, and the panel's monthly data use.
- One IoT SIM quote (Ed).
- Segmentation (Ed). Tom first checks the SG116P label and the ER706W subnet option.
- Option C trigger (Ed).
- Gate distance (Tom). Cat6 PoE to 90 m or armoured fibre.
- Lightwire CPE model (Tom). Confirm the port feeding the MC210CS is gigabit.
- Cable run actual cost (Ed). Records item only.
Cross-System Requirements How this area interacts with other systems and constraints
Source: .claude/knowledge/integration/security-infrastructure.md, v11, 2026-10-15, POPULATED. It supersedes v10 and applies Ed's 2026-10-15 rulings. Live checks of building.govt.nz, legislation.govt.nz and the DSC manual failed on 2026-10-15. Building Code clause numbers and DSC feature claims are unverified. Treat them as questions for Rotorua Lakes Council (RLC) and a DSC-certified installer.
Scope that reaches infrastructure
- 12 bays: 6 boat bays and 6 small bays. Only the 6 boat bays get readers, alarm partitions and panic buttons.
- The alarm needs 7 partitions: 6 boat bays plus one common area.
- Small-bay customers appear in the log at the gate only.
- The Phase 1 envelope for alarm, access control, UPS, opener backup, gate hardware, cabling and installation is about $13,000 to $20,000. Cameras (about $5,000) and internet (about $3,000) are separate. These are planning estimates, not quotes. Ed must approve the envelope.
Connectivity constraints from other systems
| Constraint | Source system | Effect on infrastructure |
|---|---|---|
| Worst-case upload about 3.7 Mbps, typical 1.0 to 1.5 Mbps | Cameras, access control, alarm | Fits Lightwire's 5 Mbps typical upload with about 1.3 Mbps spare |
| Peak-hour upload below 3.5 Mbps | Cameras | Limit remote view to the low-bitrate sub-stream and move clip uploads off-peak |
| Controller must decide, log and work offline | Access control | An outage never stops a PIN. Remote PIN edits and log export stop. |
| Remote access by vendor relay or outbound-only VPN | Access control, cameras | No port forwarding on any device |
| Lightwire gives carrier-grade NAT | Access control | Vendor relay is the only remote PIN route |
| Alarm needs its own SIM and LTE | Alarm, Grade 3 | Dual-path reporting passes only if the LTE test passes |
| LTE test fails on every carrier | Alarm | No dual-path and no 4G backup. Starlink, or a local siren plus a monitoring decision from Ed, follows. |
Outage behaviour required
| System | During a Lightwire outage |
|---|---|
| NVR and cameras | Keep recording |
| Gate and shed door | Valid PINs work. Events log locally. |
| Boat-bay doors | Readers work. Opener sequences run locally. |
| Alarm | Reports over LTE. PIN disarm and re-arm work. |
| Panic alert | Goes over LTE through the panel |
| Remote camera view | Lost (accepted) |
| Remote PIN edits and log export | Lost (accepted in Phase 1) |
Network layout
- Conflict C6, resolved. The TL-SG116P is probably unmanaged. Write no requirement that depends on VLANs on it.
- Cameras stay isolated on the NVR's own PoE ports.
- The communicator and controller go on a router LAN port apart from the NVR uplink, or on one flat segment with strong passwords, no port forwarding and the firewall rules.
- A small managed switch is optional and not a Phase 1 blocker.
- Segmentation matters only if an IP reader or gate unit shares the switch with the NVR. OSDP or Wiegand readers wired to the controller do not need it.
Lightwire CPE (house) -> MC210CS -> 200 m OS2 fibre -> ER706W SFP WAN (shed)
ER706W LAN -> TL-SG116P PoE switch
-> NVR uplink (camera traffic stays inside the NVR PoE ports)
ER706W LAN (separate port) -> TL280LE communicator, access controller, gate unit
ER706W WAN2 -> reserved for 4G failover (conditional)
Power layers (conflict C7, closed)
None is optional. Load is about 192W (149W core plus 43W camera PoE). Phase 2 with 6 cameras is about 214W. The 6 openers are not in these figures.
| Layer | Powers | Requirement |
|---|---|---|
| 1. AC UPS | Router, PoE switch, NVR with camera PoE, controller supply, alarm panel mains supply, PoE gate unit and PoE readers if used | Line-interactive with AVR, pure sine preferred, at least 1000 VA / 600W. USB or network port for NVR shutdown. A mains-lost signal to the alarm. |
| 2. Controller battery | Controller, 8 readers, strikes, door contacts, panic and exit circuits | 40 to 65 Ah sealed lead-acid for 24 hours (assumed draw 1.1 to 1.75 A). Replace assumed draws with datasheet figures. |
| 3. Alarm panel battery | Panel, keypad, PIRs, siren, communicator, expanders | The assumed 0.3 A gives about 19 hours on 7 Ah, short of 24. Check real standby current. Fit a larger battery in a separate enclosure if needed. |
| 4. Opener battery | 6 boat-bay roller door openers | Each Grifco LS-Drive opener has its own Battery Backup (BBU, Ed 2026-10-15; hold time unconfirmed), plus a manual inside release. Not on the central UPS. |
Runtime.
- Minimum: 10 minutes at 192W so the NVR shuts down cleanly. Under 5 minutes is refused.
- Target: 30 to 60 minutes at the 149W core load.
- A 1000 VA unit with two 9 Ah batteries gives about 59 minutes at 149W new and 44 aged. At 192W it gives about 46 new and 34 aged. Check the manufacturer's curve.
Not covered by the UPS
- The gate motor has its own 2 x 12V batteries, about 4 hours standby. After that only the manual release works. Publish the release procedure.
- The house end has no UPS. A house-end UPS (20 to 30W load, about $150 to $300) is recommended now.
- A gate-side enclosure on fibre needs its own battery-backed 12V supply.
Required power behaviour
- The alarm panel reports AC loss and low battery over LTE.
- The controller keeps checking PINs and logging on battery. Strikes stay locked from outside.
- Nobody inside is trapped with or without power. The manual inside release on each boat bay and the walk-through exit at the gate work with no power.
- The panic alert and the panic-button circuit work with no network and no mains.
- A dedicated 10A circuit with RCD at the cabinet, certified by an electrician, not shared with roller door motors or lighting. Each opener has its own mains outlet at the header. The shed's other circuits and earthing are unknown.
- Extra-low-voltage cabling stays apart from 230V, per AS/NZS 3000.
Opener battery backup and panic-open (conflicts C11 and C15)
- Ed ruled that the panic button unlocks and opens the roller door by driving the opener up. The occupant closes it.
- Tier 1 disagreement, resolved. Infrastructure v8 wires the button straight to the opener. Security-integration v6 routes it through the controller first. Both cannot be the single path.
- Resolution. Each boat-bay panic button has three isolated contacts.
- To the controller (primary). It disarms that bay's partition, waits up to about 2 seconds for confirmation, then pulses the opener if the door is not already open or moving. It logs the press. If the panel does not confirm, it opens the door anyway and alerts Tom and Ed.
- To the panel's 24-hour silent zone for that bay. This alerts Tom and Ed over LTE with the controller and internet down.
- To the opener's open input through a short delay relay (fallback when the controller is dead). The opener is a Grifco LS-Drive. Web check 2026-10-15: it can be set to open-only and timer-to-close (Ezi Roll). Its wired open input is unconfirmed. The installer sets the delay so the controller path wins when it works. The fallback can trip the door contact while armed. That is accepted.
- The panic state latches. Tom or Ed reset it.
- The opener needs a battery that raises the door after a 24-hour outage. Resolved 2026-10-15 (Ed): the openers are Grifco LS-Drive units with a BBU. Unconfirmed: how long the BBU lasts in a power cut (no page found). If the BBU cannot hold 24 hours, report it. The fallback is the manual inside release only, which does not meet the panic-open ruling in a power cut. Ed decides before accepting it.
- No boat-bay door may depend on the opener, the panic button or power as its only way out. Every boat bay keeps a manual inside release that one person can use without tools.
- If RLC says the opener-driven open makes a specified system, a compliance schedule and annual Building Warrant of Fitness (BWoF) follow, at about $300 to $800 a year (unverified).
- Needs: opener model and battery option are resolved (Ed, 2026-10-15). Still needed: the LS-Drive's open input type and manual release (Tom). Siren and re-arm rulings (Ed).
Cabling that reaches infrastructure
Boat bays. 24 home-run cables, nothing daisy-chained: reader, door contact, panic button and opener command for each of 6 bays.
- Assumed 40 m average run. About 290 m of Cat6 FTP, 290 m of 6-core and 580 m of 4-core. Replace with measured lengths.
- Keep reader runs under 80 m, or power the reader locally.
- Door contacts per boat door are open: Tier 1 security-integration assumes 2 (12 reeds), infrastructure budgets one heavy-duty contact per door. Tom confirms. Tier 3 prices both.
- Zones: 6 to 12 door contacts, 6 panic zones, the shed door, interior PIRs and tamper. A zone expander is likely.
Gate. Cat6 PoE within about 90 m, otherwise armoured fibre with a media converter. A licensed wireless bridge is the last resort.
- Own conduit, never shared with the 230V motor supply.
- Surge protection at both ends of any copper.
- Gate distance is unknown.
General
- Controller, lock power supply and battery sit inside the secure shed in a locked, tamper-switched cabinet.
- Conduit and sealed penetrations against rodents. Seal every camera fixing. Check the Totalspan cladding warranty before drilling.
- Run conduit to every planned device now, even if not yet bought.
Links to other areas
- Privacy and logging (C9). The controller holds at least 12 months of log. A monthly export goes to Max Storage's own encrypted storage for 24 months. At 24 months the credential ID is stripped from each line. The vendor is never the only copy.
- Building Warrant of Fitness (C2, C4). Electric strikes with a free mechanical inside exit are expected to avoid a BWoF. RLC has not confirmed. Get a written RLC position before any door hardware is bought.
- Fire (C3, C16). No smoke, heat or fire output on any panel zone, PGM or controller input. Phase 1 fire cover is extinguishers plus standalone battery smoke alarms in the common area and the 6 boat bays.
- Alarm grade. Design to Grade 3 features. Grade 3 is credible only if the LTE test passes. The insurer quote has been outstanding since 2026-03-28.
- Platform choice. Option A (DSC panel plus separate controller) and option B (integrated platform) both must meet the same behaviours. Ed has not chosen. Both need the same LTE path and the same power layers.
- Excluded. EasyGate (including as a backup), the Merlin E840M as a credential source, maglocks, battery or RF readers, cloud-only door decisions, and any IP or API bridge into the DSC panel.
Gaps passed to Tier 1
- G2: panic wiring disagreement between infrastructure v8 and security-integration v6. Adopt the three-contact design.
- G4: door-contact count per boat door.
- G1: building-code and health-safety still say the gate fails open. Ed ruled fail-secure.
Legal & Technical Requirements Regulatory obligations and technical standards that constrain options
Source: .claude/knowledge/technical/infrastructure-requirements.md, v8, 2026-10-15, POPULATED. v8 applies Ed's 2026-10-15 rulings. Many load figures are assumed from typical equipment, not datasheets.
Bandwidth
- The NVR records on site. Internet carries remote live view and motion clips only.
- H.265 is mandatory on every camera. H.264 roughly doubles bitrate.
- Continuous upload of 4 cameras needs at least 6.0 Mbps. That exceeds Lightwire's 5 Mbps ceiling, so it is not done.
- Worst-case upload is about 3.7 Mbps and typical is 1.0 to 1.5 Mbps.
- Minimum plan: 5 Mbps up and 10 Mbps down. Lightwire Unlimited meets this on typical figures only. Peak-hour upload (3pm to 10pm) is unmeasured.
- Access control upload (0.3 Mbps) is an assumed figure, not vendor-verified.
Power
- The shed needs one dedicated 10A circuit with RCD for the network and security cabinet. A licensed electrician installs it to AS/NZS 3000:2018 and issues the certificate of compliance.
- The circuit must not share with roller door openers or lighting.
- Each of the 6 boat-bay openers needs its own mains outlet at the header.
- Keep extra-low-voltage cabling apart from 230V.
- Earth the cabinet to the building earth. Earth the fibre armour at the shed end only.
- The shed's other circuits and earthing are unknown.
- Standards: AS/NZS 3000:2018, AS/NZS 3080:2013 (confirm edition), AS/NZS 2201.1 (edition and standby time unconfirmed), NZS 4512 only if fire detection is ever added.
UPS and batteries
- Phase 1 load is about 192W (149W non-PoE plus 43W camera PoE). Phase 2 is about 214W. Openers are excluded.
- UPS: line-interactive with AVR, at least 1000 VA / 600W, pure sine preferred, USB or network port, mains-lost signal to the alarm.
- Runtime: at least 10 minutes at 192W. Target 30 to 60 minutes at 149W.
- Controller battery: 40 to 65 Ah for 24 hours. Fail-secure hardware alone would need 12 Ah, but the 6 boat-bay readers drive the size up. Low-power readers (1W or less) or a shorter reader standby bring it down. Ed rules on standby.
- Alarm panel: the stock 7 Ah battery gives about 19 hours at an assumed 0.3 A. Confirm real current and fit a larger battery if under 24 hours.
- Gate motor: own batteries, about 4 hours standby. It stays shut on power loss.
- Openers: each needs its own backup battery that raises the door after 24 hours. Do not use a central UPS for them. Merlin battery options are unchecked.
Cabling
- House-to-shed run: complete. 200 m of 6-core OS2 armoured fibre in 25 mm conduit, at least 300 mm deep (450 mm under vehicle tracks).
- Inside the shed: Cat6 (FTP preferred) with conduit run to every planned device.
- Gate within about 90 m: outdoor Cat6 in conduit with PoE and surge protection at both ends. Beyond that, armoured fibre and a media converter. Never share conduit with the 230V motor supply.
- Boat bays: 24 home runs. Reader on Cat6 FTP, door contact on 4-core alarm cable, panic button on 6-core alarm cable, opener command on 4-core 0.5 mm2.
- Reader runs stay under 80 m. At 100 m the voltage drop is about 9.5% and marginal.
- Wiegand only under about 50 m. OSDP is preferred for long runs.
- Seal every penetration against rodents. Use UV-stable jacket where exposed.
Safety and compliance that constrain options
- Nobody inside may be trapped, with or without power. Every customer-used door has an exit that needs no PIN and no power.
- Prefer fail-secure hardware with free mechanical exit. A maglock must release on power loss, exit, panic and alarm.
- The panic button must work with no network. Release is local and the alert uses the cellular path.
- Check the final design against Building Code means of escape and the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015. Clause numbers are unverified.
- The shed door may be a specified system (SS3.2). That would mean a compliance schedule and annual BWoF. Put the question to RLC.
Network
- Camera traffic stays apart from alarm and access devices.
- TL-SG116P is believed unmanaged. The requirement is stated for managed and unmanaged cases. Check the label or admin page.
- No port forwarding. Change every default password. UPnP off. WAN remote management off. Firewall logging on. Firmware updates in the off-peak window.
- Remote access: vendor relay or an outbound-only VPN. An inbound VPN needs a public IP from Lightwire.
- NTP time in NZ local time for the controller. Log timestamps are consent evidence.
Connectivity and backup
- Lightwire Unlimited, 24 months, $139 a month, locked in. Fair-use policy is not published.
- The house end (radio, CPE, MC210CS) has no UPS. A small one (20 to 30W load) is optional in Tier 1 and recommended in Tier 2.
- The TL280LE has its own LTE path and needs its own SIM. The TL2803GR is 3G only and no longer works in NZ. The TL280E has no cellular.
- LTE signal at the shed has never been tested. It is Phase 1 critical.
- A 4G WAN2 link stays Phase 2 unless Lightwire outages prove frequent.
Open questions in Tier 1
Of 22 open questions, these touch infrastructure most: peak-hour upload (1), shed circuits (2), CPE model (3), earthing (4), communicator in hand (5), partitions and auto-arm (7), means of escape (8), gate distance and motor (9), Lightwire NAT (10), switch type (11), AS/NZS 2201.1 edition (12), LTE and SIM cost (13), insurer grade (14), reader standby (16), opener battery (18), manual release use (19), panic siren (20), boat-bay walk-through doors (21), and run lengths (22). Question 6 is closed.
Raw Research Detail Full Tier 3 agent outputs — model-by-model specs, all options assessed, sourcing notes
Internet Connectivity Options
Run 2026-10-15 against compound requirements v11. It replaces the 2026-08-05 pass (v9). Lightwire and Starlink prices, and every hardware price and stock note below, were checked on 2026-10-15 unless a line says otherwise.
Requirements Loaded
Source: /mnt/media/code/projects/Max Storage/.claude/knowledge/integration/security-infrastructure.md (v11, 2026-10-15, POPULATED). No Tier 1 document was read.
| Constraint | Detail (v11) |
|---|---|
| Worst-case upload, everything at once | About 3.7 Mbps up, 1.7 Mbps down (was 3.5 Mbps in v9) |
| Typical upload | 1.0 to 1.5 Mbps |
| Minimum plan | 5 Mbps up, 10 Mbps down |
| Peak-hour upload pass mark | At least 3.5 Mbps sustained, weekdays 3pm to 10pm. Below 3.5, limit remote view to the low-bitrate sub-stream and move clip uploads off-peak. |
| What needs the internet (new in v11) | Remote PIN add, change and revoke. Controller event push and log export. Remote camera view. Alarm app notifications over IP. |
| What must not need the internet | Door decisions, PIN checks and logging (local). NVR recording. Alarm arm and disarm. Panic alert (goes over LTE). |
| Alarm backup path | TL280LE communicator on LTE with its own SIM. Untested at the shed. The same test decides whether a 4G backup internet link works. |
| Network | TL-SG116P probably unmanaged, so no VLANs on it. Cameras stay on the NVR's own PoE ports. Communicator and controller go on a router LAN port apart from the NVR uplink. |
| Remote access | Vendor relay or outbound-only VPN. No port forwarding. |
| UPS | Router and switch on the shed UPS. House end (radio, CPE, MC210CS) has no UPS. v11 recommends a small house-end UPS. |
| Excluded | Treating the switch as VLAN-capable. Assuming LTE works at the shed. Continuous cloud upload of camera streams. A mandatory paid monitoring contract. |
What changed since the August pass. EasyGate is gone from Phase 1. Gate PINs now come from a networked controller, so an outage no longer leaves PIN management untouched. Remote PIN edits stop when Lightwire stops. Door entry does not.
Phase 1 Budget: ~$3,000 (cable run + installation + plan)
The fibre run to the shed is live (Ed's report, not re-verified by this agent). The actual invoiced cost of the trench, conduit and labour is still not reconciled against the $750 to $1,100 planning estimate. That is a records item, not a connectivity risk.
| Phase 1 internet item | NZD incl. GST | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Cable run and fibre hardware | Spent. Actual not reconciled. | Live |
| Lightwire Unlimited, 24 months | $139 a month ($1,668 a year) | Live |
| Alarm SIM | $96 to $276 a year (Option B) | New. Needs the LTE test first. |
| House-end UPS | About $150 to $300 (v11 estimate, no model chosen) | Recommended now |
| 4G backup link | $0 in Phase 1 (Option C) | Conditional |
Cable Run to Shed
Status: complete and live. Details carried forward from the earlier pass.
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Cable | 200 m 6-core OS2 LC-LC pre-terminated single-mode fibre |
| House end | TP-Link MC210CS media converter and Dynamix FSM-LCSC-1 patch lead |
| Shed end | StarTech SFPGLCLHSMST 1000BASE-LX SFP in the ER706W |
| Distance | About 200 m. OS2 is rated to 10 km, so range is not a risk. |
| Shed LAN | ER706W router, then TP-Link TL-SG116P PoE switch |
Unchanged risk. The house end has no UPS. A power cut at the house drops the shed's internet even while the shed UPS holds.
Not covered by this fibre. The gate. v11 says the gate distance from the cabinet is unknown. Cat6 PoE works to about 90 m. Beyond that the gate needs armoured fibre and a media converter. That cost sits in the access-control envelope, not here.
Lightwire Plan (re-checked 2026-10-15)
Source: lightwire.co/homes. Availability: page live and current when fetched 2026-10-15.
| Plan | Price a month | Data | Term |
|---|---|---|---|
| 90GB Low Usage | $79 | 90GB, then $0.50/GB | 12 months |
| 300GB Stream Starter | $95 | 300GB, then $0.50/GB | 12 months |
| Unlimited (Ed's plan) | $139 | Unlimited | 24 months |
| Unlimited | $155 | Unlimited | 12 months |
The $139 price is unchanged since 2026-08-05. The page still publishes no speeds, no fair-use policy and no word on public IP versus carrier-grade NAT. The 5 Mbps up and 10 Mbps down figures come from earlier correspondence with Lightwire. They are not on the public site. The site's "free install" value now reads "usually $490" in one place and "valued at $650" in another. Neither applies to Ed's live connection.
| Requirement | Verdict |
|---|---|
| 5 Mbps up | PARTIAL. Typical figure only. Peak hours unmeasured. |
| 10 Mbps down | PASS |
| No data cap | PASS |
| Worst-case 3.7 Mbps up fits | PASS on the typical figure, with about 1.3 Mbps spare. Unproven at peak. |
| Fair-use policy | OPEN. Not published. Get it in writing. |
| Public IP or CGNAT | OPEN. Not published. Decides the remote PIN route (see Remote Access). |
No evidence of a competing fixed line or fibre provider at Te Waerenga Road. Ed is under a 24-month contract. Do not switch.
Connectivity Options
Option A: Lightwire Unlimited, 24 months (primary, live)
- Spec: $139 a month, unlimited data, ER706W at the shed.
- Compliance: download PASS. Upload PARTIAL (peak unmeasured). Fair use and NAT answers OPEN.
- Phase 1 cost: $139 a month. Hardware $0. Source: lightwire.co/homes. Availability: confirmed live 2026-10-15.
- Phase 2/3 path: no change to this link. Add Option C beside it.
- Locks in: the 24-month term.
- Risks: upload is not guaranteed. Peak-hour congestion is the biggest unknown in the plan. Lightwire is also the single path for remote PIN edits.
Option B: Alarm LTE path (TL280LE SIM) (Phase 1, needed for the alarm)
What it carries. Alarm reports, panic, AC loss and tamper alerts when Lightwire is down. It is the path that makes the alarm dual-path. It does not carry general internet. It has its own SIM and does not depend on Option C.
Facts checked, and gaps.
- DSC lists the TL280LE as "SIM Card (included)" for North America and names only Bell, Rogers and AT&T variants. Source: DSC TL280LE product pageE/TL280LE(R)E%20-%20PowerSeries%20Neo%20LTE/HSPA/Internet%20Cellular/Dual%20Path%20Alarm%20Communicator/2639). The page lists no LTE bands and no NZ carrier.
- US resellers say the AT&T variant works only with AT&T. Source: Alarm System Store. A bundled-SIM unit is the wrong unit for NZ.
- Search found no NZ price and no NZ distributor for the TL280LE. A Swedish listing shows an EU variant (Ahlsell). It is the likely NZ-compatible unit. This is a lead, not a confirmation.
source-alarmsowns the unit and its price. - Whether the EU unit covers the 700 MHz band (band 28) that rural NZ coverage leans on is unverified (recall only). Ask the installer for the band list.
SIM plan choices (all NZD incl. GST, checked 2026-10-15). The panel sends very little data. The exact monthly volume is unverified. Ask the installer or DSC.
| Choice | Monthly | Yearly | Notes | Source and availability |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2degrees prepay, Monthly $8 | $8 | $96 | Data amount not shown on the page. Auto-renews while credit lasts. Unused data carries over up to 12 months. 2degrees rural coverage is the weakest of the three (recall, unverified). | 2degrees prepay. Page live 2026-10-15. |
| One NZ prepay, Rollover Small | $18 | $216 | Price from 22 April 2026. Data amount and expiry not shown on the page. | One NZ plan changes. Page live 2026-10-15. |
| Spark prepaid Value Pack, $18 | $18 | $216 | 1GB, 100 minutes, unlimited texts. Rollover. A 5GB bonus applies only to new customers who port a number. | Spark prepaid. Page live 2026-10-15. |
| Spark prepaid Value Pack, $23 | $23 | $276 | 2GB rollover. Gives headroom. | Same page. |
| One NZ IoT Data Bundle or Pay As You Go | Not published | Not published | Monthly fee per connection plus data. Prices exclude GST. No minimum term stated. Quote via iot.nz@one.nz. | One NZ IoT plans. Page live, no prices. |
| Spark Business IoT | Not published | Not published | Quote only. | Spark Business IoT. Carried forward from 2026-08-05. Not re-fetched. |
| M2M One (NZ reseller) | Not published for NZ | Not published for NZ | Its Australian list shows about A$1.47 to A$7.50 a SIM a month for small pooled plans. That is a hint, not an NZ price. | M2M One NZ. Pricing gated. AU list. |
Prepay risks for an unattended alarm.
- The plan lapses if credit runs out. Set auto top-up on a card Max Storage owns, and put the renewal date in Tom's calendar.
- Prepay terms may bar machine-to-machine use. This is unverified. Ask the carrier in writing before buying.
- A prepay SIM has no business support if the panel stops reporting.
Cost and fit. The v11 estimate of $15 to $25 a month ($180 to $300 a year) is consistent with One NZ or Spark prepay. 2degrees costs less but only if the signal test passes on it. An IoT SIM from a quote could cost less again and has proper support. Get one quote to compare.
Compliance. Dual-path alarm reporting: PASS if the LTE test passes, FAIL if it does not (see test below). Needs its own SIM: PASS.
Phase 1 cost: SIM $96 to $276 a year, as its own line. Antenna (if signal is weak): price at sourcing, unverified.
What this locks in: nothing contractual on prepay.
LTE signal test at the shed (Tom)
This one test decides both the alarm path (Option B) and whether Option C works. Do it once, with the peak-hour Lightwire upload test in the same visit.
- First pass, no visit. Look up the address on the Spark, One NZ and 2degrees coverage maps. A map shows a predicted signal, not a measured one.
- Get a phone on each network. Borrow phones or buy the cheapest prepay SIM from each carrier. Whichever carrier wins becomes the alarm SIM, so the test SIM is not wasted.
- Test at the cabinet. Stand where the TL280LE will sit, at that height, with the shed door shut. Steel cladding cuts signal.
- Read the signal.
- Android: Settings, About phone, SIM status, signal strength. It shows dBm.
- iPhone: field test mode may work (dial
3001#12345#). It depends on the iOS version. This is unverified.
- Record three things per carrier: signal strength in dBm, whether the phone shows 4G or LTE (not 3G), and a speed test.
- Repeat at a weekday peak time (3pm to 10pm) and at a quiet time.
- Read the result with these rule-of-thumb bands (unverified for this unit):
| Reading (RSRP) | Meaning | Action |
|---|---|---|
| -95 dBm or stronger | Good | Fit the communicator at the cabinet. 4G backup (Option C) is viable. |
| -95 to -105 dBm | Usable | Fit it. Test again after install. Consider an external antenna. |
| -105 to -115 dBm | Weak | External antenna on the communicator. Option C is doubtful. |
| Weaker than -115 dBm, or 3G only | Fail on that carrier | Try the next carrier. If all fail, v11 applies: Lightwire only, no dual-path, no Option C. Starlink or a local siren and a monitoring decision from Ed follow. |
- Send the table to the installer with the carrier ranking, so they confirm the SIM and antenna choice.
Option C: 4G backup internet link on the ER706W WAN2 (Phase 2, conditional)
Is it worth it? Yes, but not before the data says so. The reasons for and against:
- For. Remote PIN edits are now a Phase 1 function. During a Lightwire outage Tom and Ed cannot add a customer, revoke a PIN or export a log. Remote camera view is also lost. Cost is low: about $158 once, plus about $276 to $336 a year.
- Against. Nothing safety-critical depends on it. Doors, recording, alarm and panic all run without internet. The alarm already has its own LTE path. The outage cost is a delay to PIN edits, which Tom can make on site. We do not know how often Lightwire drops.
- Rule. Buy it if the LTE test passes and either (a) the router log shows more than one outage of an hour or more in a quarter, or (b) an outage blocks a customer from getting access. The ER706W WAN2 port stays free until then.
What falls back to 4G and what does not.
| System | During a Lightwire outage, with Option C | Without Option C |
|---|---|---|
| Remote PIN add, change, revoke | Works over 4G | Lost |
| Log export, event push | Works over 4G | Lost |
| Remote camera view | Works, but limit it to the sub-stream (see data below) | Lost |
| Door and gate PINs | Work locally | Work locally |
| NVR recording | Works locally | Works locally |
| Alarm, panic, AC-loss and tamper alerts | Go over the alarm's own LTE SIM | Same |
Hardware (checked 2026-10-15).
| Item | Price (NZD incl. GST) | Source and availability |
|---|---|---|
| TP-Link TL-MR6400 4G LTE router (N300, Cat4) | $158 at PB Tech. Range seen over 3 months: $139 to $159. Two other shops listed at $159 and $205.50. | PriceSpy listing: PB Tech shown in stock, fetched 2026-10-15. Direct PB Tech page returns 403 to this agent: PB Tech product page. Not page-confirmed at the retailer. |
| TP-Link ER706W-4G (replaces the ER706W; 4G modem built in) | $630.19 at Comsys, out of stock, 2 to 4 weeks. $647.99 at PB Tech, "only 3 left" per search. | Comsys: out of stock 2026-10-15. PB Tech: found via search, not page-confirmed. |
Discontinuation check. TP-Link's end-of-life table lists MR6400 v1 to v3 only (last October 2019). It does not list v5. TP-Link released v5.20 firmware in July 2024. Sources: Omada bulletin, TP-Link MR6400 v5.20 download page. No supersession found. Check the hardware version on the box is v5.
Recommended hardware: MR6400. Replacing the ER706W with the ER706W-4G costs about four times as much for the same job, and it is out of stock. The MR6400 plugs into WAN2 as a second internet source. It sits behind the ER706W's NAT, which is fine for failover.
Data for the backup SIM. One camera sub-stream at 0.5 to 1.0 Mbps uses roughly 225 to 450 MB an hour (arithmetic, not measured). Block camera streams on WAN2 with a firewall rule so a short outage cannot burn the allowance.
| Choice | Monthly | Yearly | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spark prepaid, 2GB rollover | $23 | $276 | Spark prepaid |
| Spark prepaid, 3GB rollover | $28 | $336 | Same page |
| Spark prepaid, 4.5GB rollover | $40 | $480 | Same page |
| One NZ prepay, Rollover Medium | $23 | $276 | One NZ plan changes. Data amount not shown. |
| 2degrees prepay, Monthly $25 | $25 | $300 | 2degrees prepay. Data amount not shown. |
| IoT SIM (One NZ, Spark Business, M2M One) | Quote | Quote | See Option B table. |
Use a different carrier from the alarm SIM if both pass the test. One network outage then cannot take out both paths.
Phase 2 cost: $158 plus $276 to $336 a year. Locks in: nothing. Risk: the LTE test. Rural 4G upload is lower and more variable than Lightwire. It is acceptable as failover, not as a primary link.
Option D: Starlink (fallback only, not recommended)
Use only if the LTE test fails on every carrier. Prices below come from secondary sources. The Starlink NZ site returned no content to this agent. Re-quote at starlink.com/nz with the address before deciding.
| Item | NZD | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Residential Standard | $170 a month (up from $159 in mid-June 2026) | Budget Seniors, Aug/Sept 2026, Moneybalance |
| Residential Lite | $85 a month | Carried forward from 2026-08-05. Not re-confirmed. |
| Hardware | About $799. Rural free-hardware or discount offers exist. | Budget Seniors, Farmers Weekly |
At $170 a month it costs more than Lightwire ($139). Note one more point for a failed LTE test: Starlink would restore only the remote functions. It would not give the alarm a second path.
Network Layout and the Switch Question
Is the TL-SG116P unmanaged? Almost certainly yes. Retailer data sheets list it as "Unmanaged", plug-and-play, with 16 PoE+ ports and a 120W budget. Sources: MyITHub, PB Tech (found via search, page returns 403 to this agent). The PB Tech NZ price in search snapshots was $217.98 to $243. TP-Link's own page could not be fetched. A switch with no admin page confirms it. Tom checks.
The listings name an "Isolation Mode" and a "Priority Mode". Isolation Mode normally stops the downstream ports talking to each other and lets them reach only the uplink ports. That is a free, partial form of segmentation. Which ports it covers is unverified. Check the manual.
Does Phase 1 need segmentation? No.
- Cameras are already isolated on the NVR's own PoE ports.
- The only reason to go further is to keep the alarm communicator and access controller away from other devices on the shed LAN. With no guest Wi-Fi and no third-party devices, that risk is small.
- The earlier VLAN 10 and VLAN 20 plan assumed a managed switch. It is withdrawn.
Phase 1 layout (no new hardware).
- NVR uplink to one ER706W LAN port.
- Communicator and controller to a separate ER706W LAN port, not through the NVR.
- Check whether the ER706W can put that port on its own subnet without a managed switch. Forum posts on the older TL-R605 say no. Posts on the ER706W conflict. This is unconfirmed. Test it in the admin page. It costs nothing.
- If it cannot, run one flat network. Rely on strong unique passwords, no port forwarding, UPnP off and the firewall rules below.
If segmentation is required (Ed's call). The router carries VLAN tags (the ER706W supports 802.1Q per PB Tech spec sheet via search). A managed switch splits ports into VLANs and trunks to the router.
| Option | Price (NZD incl. GST) | PoE | Fit | Source and availability |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| TP-Link TL-SG108PE, 8-port Easy Smart | $126.15 at Comsys. About $113 at PB Tech per search. | 4 PoE ports, 55W | Cheapest managed step. Port, tag and MTU VLAN. Hang it off the SG116P or a router port for the alarm and controller VLAN only. | Comsys: in stock 2026-10-15. Comsys page shows a stray "45" port count in its specs. Confirm. |
| TP-Link Omada SG2210P, 8-port PoE+ smart | $243.03 at Comsys | 8 PoE+ ports. 53W or 61W, sources conflict. | Handles 4 cameras on PoE (about 32W) if the NVR is bypassed. Not needed with an NVR. | Comsys: in stock 2026-10-15. |
| TP-Link Omada SG2218P, 16-port PoE+ | $459 at PB Tech. Comsys shows $492.19 on order and an older $411.69 out of stock. | 16 ports, 150W | Replaces the SG116P outright. Only if PoE demand grows in Phase 3. | PB Tech: found via search, not page-confirmed. Comsys: conflicting listings. |
Switch recommendation. Keep the SG116P. Add nothing in Phase 1. If Ed rules that segmentation is required, add the SG108PE. It is the least costly managed switch and carries only the alarm and controller VLAN. The SG2218P is a Phase 3 replacement, not a Phase 1 need.
Do not size the PoE budget on the SG116P from memory. The SG116P budget is 120W. Four cameras draw about 32W. The gate unit and any PoE readers add to it. source-access-control must state their draw.
Firewall rules (ER706W). No port forwarding. UPnP off. WAN remote management off. Logging on. Firmware and scheduled updates run between midnight and 8am. Change every default password (router, switch, cameras, NVR, controller). Block camera streams on WAN2.
Remote-access method for the controller.
- If Lightwire gives a public IP: vendor relay or an outbound-only VPN. Still no port forward.
- If Lightwire uses carrier-grade NAT: vendor relay only. The ER706W supports WireGuard and OpenVPN, but a VPN into a NAT-ed site needs an outside server.
Offline Behaviour
| System | Lightwire down | Lightwire and house power down | Source of the claim |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gate and shed door PINs | Work. Events log locally. | Work on the controller battery. | v11 outage table |
| Boat-bay readers and opener sequences | Work locally | Work on the controller battery. Opener needs its own backup (v11 C15). | v11 |
| NVR and cameras | Record | Record while the shed UPS lasts (target 30 to 60 min at 149W) | v11 |
| Alarm arm, disarm, re-arm | Work | Work on the panel battery | v11 |
| Alarm reports and panic alert | Go over LTE | Go over LTE while the panel battery lasts | v11 |
| Remote PIN edits, log export | Lost (Option C restores) | Lost | v11 |
| Remote camera view | Lost (Option C restores, sub-stream only) | Lost | v11 |
Fails entirely only if the LTE test fails. Then the alarm has no second path and v11 C5 applies.
Gap in the UPS plan. The house end has no UPS. A house power cut kills internet at the shed while the shed UPS still runs. The alarm is unaffected. Remote PIN edits are lost. Fit a UPS at the house end, rated for a 20 to 30W load (CPE, media converter and any radio). v11 estimates $150 to $300. No model is chosen here. Choose and live-check one at purchase.
Recommended Setup
Phase 1.
- Lightwire Unlimited 24-month (Option A). Live. Keep it.
- Alarm SIM (Option B). Run the LTE test first. Pick the strongest carrier. Prepay at $96 to $276 a year is enough to start. Get one IoT SIM quote to compare.
- House-end UPS. About $150 to $300. Remote PIN edits are now a Phase 1 function and this protects them from a house power cut.
- Keep the TL-SG116P. Flat network, firewall rules, communicator and controller on a separate router port. Test whether the ER706W can give that port its own subnet.
- No 4G backup yet.
Phase 2, if the trigger is met (Option C). Buy the TL-MR6400 ($158) and a prepay SIM on a different carrier from the alarm ($276 to $336 a year). Run it in failover mode on WAN2. Block camera streams on it.
Why. The alarm's own LTE path covers every safety-critical alert. Lightwire covers the rest. The 4G link only restores remote PIN edits and camera view, so it needs a measured outage problem to justify itself.
Network Configuration Notes
WAN failover (when Option C is added). WAN1 is Lightwire (primary). WAN2 is the 4G router (failover only, not load-balancing). Health checks use 8.8.8.8 and 1.1.1.1 on both links.
Speed test and upload monitoring.
- Run speedtest.net or fast.com from the shed during weekday peak (3pm to 10pm). Upload should hold at or above 3.5 Mbps.
- Compare the shed reading with the house-end reading. A gap points at the media converter, SFP or fibre.
- Review the router's WAN bandwidth log monthly for upload consumers that should not exist (for example accidental NVR cloud backup).
- Keep an outage log from now. It supplies the Option C trigger.
Open Questions
- Peak-hour upload test at the shed (Tom). Highest priority. Pass is 3.5 Mbps sustained, weekdays 3pm to 10pm. Still unmeasured.
- LTE signal test (Tom). Method above. It gates the alarm purchase and Option C.
- Lightwire in writing (Ed). Public IP or carrier-grade NAT, and the fair-use policy. Call 0800 12 13 14 or the business line 0800 534 567 (numbers carried forward from the earlier pass, not re-checked).
- Which TL280LE unit and SIM (Tom, installer). Does the NZ unit have a bundled carrier SIM or an open slot? Which LTE bands does it cover, including band 28?
- SIM terms (Ed). Ask the chosen carrier whether prepay allows a machine-to-machine device. Ask the installer how much data the panel uses each month.
- One IoT SIM quote (Ed). From One NZ (iot.nz@one.nz) or M2M One, to compare with prepay.
- Segmentation (Ed). Is it required? If yes, the SG108PE is the lowest-cost route. Tom first checks the SG116P label and whether the ER706W can split a port onto its own subnet.
- Option C trigger (Ed). Agree the rule above: more than one outage of an hour or more in a quarter, or an outage that blocks a customer.
- Gate distance (Tom). Cat6 PoE to 90 m or armoured fibre. Cost sits with access control.
- CPE model (Tom). Confirm the Lightwire CPE model at the house and that the port feeding the MC210CS is gigabit.
- Cable run actual cost (Ed). Reconcile against the $750 to $1,100 estimate. Records item only.